American Civil War Battlefield Surgeon CW049 (1 Viewer)

oberstoskar

Sergeant
Joined
Jul 23, 2006
Messages
628
It's strange that the civil war surgeon wore a white coat.

The white coat was not introduced until very late 1800's and even so it was not very popular at that period.

There are many paintings in Johns Hopkins Hospital (where I used to work) doctors wore black attire a century ago.

Any doctors in this forum?
 
Ober,
Perhaps somebody like Brad who might have a few different ACW movies and books can have a look and rule out white coats in the ACW.

If you care to look at the Britains ACW Union surgeon set he does not appear to be wearing black. A Google images search brings up an image of a ACW surgeon / doctor re-enactor wearing a white jacket. I would guess it would be hard to rule out ACW doctors wearing white jackets. I have no idea when white jackets came in but if you were a Union Dr wearing black you are going to be easily mistaken for a blue coat. White seems logical.

Regards
Brett
 
I don't really know the answer. I did a quick internet search and saw a couple of photos of doctors/surgeons wearing dark clothing but I wouldn't call that exhaustive research.
 
It's strange that the civil war surgeon wore a white coat.

The white coat was not introduced until very late 1800's and even so it was not very popular at that period.

There are many paintings in Johns Hopkins Hospital (where I used to work) doctors wore black attire a century ago.

Any doctors in this forum?

Most of the photos of the period were posed, so that all the doctors are shown in full uniform. I did find some period photos showing an apron, but they were protected from being copied...Most all the reinactors photos show the surgeon wearing a white apron. I usually trust their research into most ACW matters and this is probably what the doctors wore during surgery...Michael

PS..Found this photo of a civil war doctors white coat in a museum. It was with instruments of the period and the coat still shows blood stains..Bardstown museum website...
 

Attachments

  • youraaos5-1.gif
    youraaos5-1.gif
    50.2 KB · Views: 800
  • post-271-1223983928.jpg
    post-271-1223983928.jpg
    64.8 KB · Views: 1,983
  • 1.-Civil-War-200x300.jpg
    1.-Civil-War-200x300.jpg
    21.9 KB · Views: 922
Last edited:
Federal military doctors would wear a Federal officers uniform conforming to the regulations of the time when possible. The same would hold true for Confederate medical officers... clothing that would reflect their organization's regulations when possible. These would not be civilians.

Protective clothing:
White or even unbleached cotton or linen clothing was used for all kinds of protective clothing during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. This could include farm smocks, hunting shirts, work jackets and tradesman's aprons. This is for a simple and practical reason...it can be easily washed, and bleached if needed. Remember that this is the period before wool garments could easily be cleaned. Summer weight clothing was often white too.

Many surviving black wool frock coats and civilian sack coats were not originally made as black garments, but were over-dyed to mask staining to extend the life of the garment. Men wear stuff out and then throw it away... women generally do not if their socioeconomic status allows replacement or up to date fashions.

As far as black clothing goes in period art, The color pallet for mens clothing was already pretty limited by radical fashion changes during the Regency period. Many professionals in formal attire were depicted in black frock coats and dark trousers.
We still wear some combination of Dark Blue, Black, Gray, or Brown upper clothing and White, Tan, Gray, Dark Blue or Black trousers to this day as a result.

Hope this helps,
Ken
 
Thanks for your expert input, guys!

A white apron is more historically correct than a white jacket for civil war surgeons

By the way, I believe scientists or chemist commonly wore the white coat way before doctors. That's why it is also known as the 'Lab coat.' Doctors practicing Western medicine took the idea of wearing a white coat because they wanted to impress people that medicine was also about science (medicine used to be 'witch craft' in ancient times)
 
it's strange that the civil war surgeon wore a white coat.

The white coat was not introduced until very late 1800's and even so it was not very popular at that period.

There are many paintings in johns hopkins hospital (where i used to work) doctors wore black attire a century ago.

Any doctors in this forum?

watch the movie the horse soldiers, the asst doctor is wearing a white long coat over his uniform, and that being one of my favorite movies i am siding with them
 
watch the movie the horse soldiers, the asst doctor is wearing a white long coat over his uniform, and that being one of my favorite movies i am siding with them

ha ha Hollywood is well-known for its history gaffe

but I understand that K&C often trades off historical accuracy for aestheticism, which is OK!
 
ha ha Hollywood is well-known for its history gaffe

but I understand that K&C often trades off historical accuracy for aestheticism, which is OK!

I'm not surprised that you would say that:wink2:
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top