"For many years, students of the Battle of Gettysburg have sung the praises of the Spencer rifle and its contribution to the great Union victory. Numerous authors have suggested that it was the Spencer that helped derail the Confederate attack on the morning of July 1; that General John Buford’s cavalry troopers, armed with their Spencer carbines, repelled wave after wave of Confederate infantry. The contributions of the Spencer to Union victory are not limited to July 1st however. Captain O. E. Hunt, U.S. Army, and Instructor at the U.S.M.A. wrote in his report on The Ordnance Department of the Federal Army: 1860-1865, about the superiority of the Spencer rifle and its use by General John Geary’s 12th Corps soldiers on July 2nd. “Due to the use of the Spencer rifle by part of General Geary’s troops at Gettysburg, a whole division of Ewell’s corps was repulsed by inferior numbers.” Captain Hunt continues: “ Of this action an eye-witness said, ’ The head of the column ( Confederate) , as it was pushed on by those behind, appeared to melt away or sink into the earth, for though continually moving, it got no nearer.’” As we shall see, Hunt’s report made for stirring reading but like many references about Spencers and Gettysburg it had no foundation in fact."
Black Hawk's depiction is thus going to be very well received: historically accurate for the 5th and 6th Michigan Cavalry on that epic July 3 fight at East Cavalry Field while Pickett's charge was occuring over at Cemetary Ridge. It is very refreshing to see historical myth's debunked by a well thought out introduction of cleverly depicted troops like Buford's cavalry using this recently introduced weapon day 1 at Gettysburg, the careless application of yellow stripes to enlisted troopers trousers, disregard for reading and interpreting official ordnance records, period photgraphs and written descriptions by actual participants. A great Memorial Day weekend rollout of an occurence almost 150 years ago.