Ebay~~~~~~~~Strange days indeed! (1 Viewer)

mikemiller1955

Lieutenant General
Joined
Aug 3, 2008
Messages
17,490
I have seen quite a few threads, discussions and comments on this forum concerning "odd" Ebay purchases.

Mostly over the incredulous prices and the skepticism of how "uninformed" people buy or try to sell them at ridiculous "off market" prices on Ebay.

The posts commenting, that collectors and Treefrogger's are amazed at the bizarre prices paid on Ebay, for

"out of stock"

or

"still in stock"

of the Battle of Monongahela sets and Woodland Indians sets.

Matt at Hobby Bunker still has sets of VM02 and VM03 at msrp.

I spoke to them this morning and they have,

3 sets of VM02 @$72

and

2 sets of VM03 @ $72.

Just thought I would let the serious JJ collectors know.

Michael
 
Bought my QR01 from the Antique Center in Gettysburg for $92 about a month ago. Apparently now it's worth $250... to someone. Hate to be the poor uninformed guy that pays that without doing his research. Also had a collector I know pay $250 for a single figure I picked up for $81. Other than maybe the early BM stuff the figures are out there and they do come up at reasonable prices if you are patient. What might be a good idea for this forum would be for the dealers to list what they have on a regular basis, even once a month - since most of them are members of this forum. Sure help the guys looking and especially new collectors. I've got an article I wrote for Toy Soldier Collector coming out in issue 27 on this very subject. Hope the point gets across. Cheers.
 
Last edited:
Always, always check your local dealers and then ebay. Or the other way around but check somewhere first. Check with Treefrog, Hobby Bunker or Sierra. They may have the items. If you are lucky enough to have a shop in your area go there! Strike up a conversation if they are not busy. I am lucky to have Sierra nearby and they treat me very well. The dealers are your friends and scouts in Toy Soldier collecting.:D
 
Bought my QR01 from the Antique Center in Gettysburg for $92 about a month ago. Apparently now it's worth $250... to someone. Hate to be the poor uninformed guy that pays that without doing his research. Also had a collector I know pay $250 for a single figure I picked up for $81. Other than maybe the early BM stuff the figures are out there and they do come up at reasonable prices if you are patient. What might be a good idea for this forum would be for the dealers to list what they have on a regular basis, even once a month - since most of them are members of this forum. Sure help the guys looking and especially new collectors. I've got an article I wrote for Toy Soldier Collector coming out in issue 27 on this very subject. Hope the point gets across. Cheers.

Yes, an updated inventory on this forum would be nice.

I guess it's hard for the retailers to update their websites daily and I'm sure mistakes do happen.

I know that Larry Simmons has some WHRR's in stock that are not on his website and he is usually very good about updating his site.

He told me he had put some aside for his regular customers and was not listing them on his website, lol, I dunno, but he's always been pretty straight with me.

Troops of Time's site is showing some VM03's in stock.

Please post a copy of your article on the John Jenkin's forum so I don't miss it, I would love to read that,

Michael
 
Hey Michael, The dealers have been awesome - all around the world. A call to any one of them would get someone the answer they need before heading off to Ebay or even bothering to consider the bloated options they have. I have noticed a recent trend however... for some sellers... to place the items at near retail. The other thing I notice is that when Jenkins announces something is "retired" - even though it may still be readily available at retail - it sets off this pavlovian drooling response and the next day there's a slew of highly priced "hard to find""retired""rare" Jenkins sets on Ebay. If you want something ask the dealers, they are the ones who have invested in the business of toys and can certainly help to answer your question if not even direct you, second are the members of this forum - many of whom are willing to sell off items for much the same as they paid or at least help to direct you to other sources, and third Ebay - but only if you have done your homework first - unlike the poor guy I know who bought the fake canoe and 4 French paddlers off Ebay just recently from overseas. Lets keep the hobby growing for all of us - especially new collectors - since that is what John Jenkins needs to continue doing what he does best. Cheers, ssorc1
 
One problem is that many dealers have out of date websites or no website like the GB Antique Center. So often collectors aren't even aware of them.
 
One problem is that many dealers have out of date websites or no website like the GB Antique Center. So often collectors aren't even aware of them.

Yes - But most all of them (including Antique Center of Gettysburg) have phone numbers and/or e-mail addresses for inquiries. It is often too time intensive to constantly update a website with available and/or sold out items especially when dealing with items that sell so rapidly.
Stan
 
Hey
SSORC,

I couldn't agree more. It behooves a buyer to contact the dealer first.

So many people sell their sets back to the dealers and move in another direction. I have several sources that have called me in the past when they get some "retired" sets that they know i'm collecting come in to their store.

I think that some of the sellers on Ebay are pricing at near retail or lower just to "cash in" and use the money for something else. Maybe they have grown tired of that figure and would rather sell it and apply the money to something else.

With shipping per item, it's really not that big of a bargain, in fact, if you get a decent "discount" from your retailer, it's no bargain at all.

The "retired disclaimer" effect you mention, does ring the bell and make the dogs salivate though.

However, just because it's "retired", "rare" or "hard to find", does not mean it can't be found on a shelf in three different stores at msrp.

I have always been amazed at how someone feels they can dictate the market on Ebay, some of the prices are unreal and I have just told myself,

"I will learn to live without it".

So far, I still sleep well and have not missed one meal yet, :D:D:D:D:D

Life goes on.

I have noticed threads on Treefrog, purposely mentiong that a piece is "retired" and it seems like a few days later, you will see it all over Ebay at an inflated price.

Your 1-2-3 process is spot on.

(1) Dealer (Father Knows Best)
(2) Treefrog members (Mostly fair deals through mutual respect, comraderie or their desire to relinquish and move on to something else.
(3) Ebay/Evilbay (Last resort, check the market first or you could pay double or triple the msrp.)

COMBAT,

That is a problem, some of those websites are outdated, misleading and don't actually reflect the availabilty of that retailer's product.

A phone call is necessary on any purchase I think.

ANY PURCHASE!!!

I exhaust all resources before I go to Ebay. Check all the retailers and check them well.

www.soldiergallery.com is listed on John's site as a retialer, but I can't even navigate his website.

Every link or tab I click on his website takes you to either K&C products or somewhere else. I even searched the name, "John Jenkins" on it and came up with mothing.

I mentioned earlier in this thread, just call, some retailers find a website hard to maintain current and some prefer not to use it at all.

TECHNOLOGY, lol:eek::eek::eek::eek::eek:

Michael
 
Yes - But most all of them (including Antique Center of Gettysburg) have phone numbers and/or e-mail addresses for inquiries. It is often too time intensive to constantly update a website with available and/or sold out items especially when dealing with items that sell so rapidly.
Stan

Agreed, very true!

How long does a phone call take? ;););)

Michael
 
Mike.
you are not alone about the Toy Soldier Gallery.Maybe they had Jenkins at one time but haven't in a while.
Mark
 
Mike.
you are not alone about the Toy Soldier Gallery.Maybe they had Jenkins at one time but haven't in a while.
Mark

Mark,

They have John Jenkin's in their shop.

Just like stan and Combat said, some retailers don't keep a current website, for whatever reason.

Their phone number is on the site.

They might have something you are looking for.

Good luck hunting.

Michael
 
Wow,

Ebay is flooded today with BM's. Five listings just on BM's.

I have never seen so many of John's pieces on there at one time.

Multiple listings on several other sets on John Jenkins.

BM10 is jumping all over the place.

VM02 is still available in stores at msrp.

Lots of dealers have gone to Ebay.

This is getting funny.

Michael
 
Just seen the whaleboat on ebay.Not asking much more than retail price.It is being sold by a dealer who I know is a very nice person.Maybe he can't sell this item though his store and wants to expand his customer base.I sometimes think it isn't ethical for a dealer to do this but maybe they have reasons I don't know about.

Mark
 
I don't feel that it is right for the dealers to go to ebay to sell items from their stores.It just doesn't seem ethical IMO.
Mark

I don't know Mark, that doesn't bother me too much,

unless it is at a "much inflated" price over the manufacturer's msrp.

To speculate on figures can be risky or it can be profitable, but they are risking their own money.

I don't ask anyone's opinion on how I speculate on stocks or any of my investments. It's a gamble.

However, according to one of the retailers I spoke to, and who will remain anonymous because he is a good friend of mine and has always treated me well,

he said, and again this is his interpretation of his contract with John,

That John Jenkins, who kind of frowns on it too, allows the retailers to sell only "retired" items on EBay. Once John retires a figure from his factory, the retailers can do as they please. That is their agreement in his opinion and he can choose any market he wants to sell it after it's retired.

No problem for me there either. Sell it here, sell it there, what does it matter.

The retailers are not allowed to sell sets on EBay that are not "retired" according to this distributor.

Once it goes retired, it's open market.

Now I see this "pre-retired" selling happening anyway, and this may be some loose interpretation of the "rules", but it is what it is.

Again, the only thing that bothers is when the retailer offers the "retired" EBay set at a huge price over the suggested msrp.

He can control the after market prices once an item is retired with his unsold inventory.

He has first crack at ordering from John and he can stockpile sets and wait for their retirement, but we can stockpile too.

The only real quandary I have now, is where does my loyalty stand now as a consumer to my retailer that is "gouging" me.

Example: One retailer orders a lot of a certain set and sits on them, locked in a vault for a year, until they become retired.

Once they become "retired", their value increases, theoretically.

Now he opens the vault and theoretically can make a good profit on his speculation by overcharging the msrp.

However, maybe nobody wants them and he's stuck with them.

So, if they bought 50 sets of BM01 (@ $69) and just put them in a safe for 2 years, when John retired them, he theoretically could sell them for a whole lot more.

Now that could be a problem for me and I would blackball that retailer from any further business. I would find it hard to do business with him in the future if he stuck it to me on EBay.

I don't mind someone getting a little piece of the cheese, but don't be a pig. The pig gets fat and the hog gets slaughtered.

Distributors do sometimes buy retired pieces from individuals at inflated prices, so why shouldn't they have a chance to make a little extra on the side?

I don't know, you can look at it so many ways.

Just like anybody else, I don't like to be taken advantage of. You screw me once and the next time I need something, I will look elsewhere before I contact you.

However, I'm not going to pass up a good deal either on something I want.

I think I have just learned to live without some things that I feel bad about paying so much more.

It's not a question of the money, but I almost feel stupid and ashamed that I would allow myself to be taken for a ride.

I missed a lot of sets on the BM series that I wanted, but I have lost no sleep, missed no meals and suffered no ill effects over it, lol.

I really don't no problem with an individual (not a distributor), risking his money and speculating. That's America.

The bottom line is that, "It is what it is".

I don't make the rules, but I love the game.

I just don't know how to figure this.

Michael
 
Just seen the whaleboat on ebay.Not asking much more than retail price.It is being sold by a dealer who I know is a very nice person.Maybe he can't sell this item though his store and wants to expand his customer base.I sometimes think it isn't ethical for a dealer to do this but maybe they have reasons I don't know about.

Mark

He is also giving free shipping, hardly making a killing in my opinion, and he is a "peach of a guy" too.

Michael
 
Personally, I don't care much if someone is buying up sets so long as there is a reasonable opportunity to purchase an item at retail from the dealer. That has never been a problem with JJ or any other manufacturer. If I pass or wait too long then it's only fair to the manufacturer that someone else buys their products even if it is a "speculator." If you make arrangements with a dealer they are more than accomodating in most instances. Most will even hold items for you - at least for a while. I can understand some frustration with those trying to make a quick profit on ebay or fudging on the availability of certain items, but again the information and dealers are out there for collectors who take a few minutes to consult them.

My advice is that if John releases a set limited to 350 or less, you need to buy it asap to ensure that you will get it at retail. However, most releases are over 350. In which case you have months or longer to decide.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top