I went to Gettysburg again a few weeks ago. I bought my first toy soldiers at at Greystone's American History Bookstore there years ago, but the best toy soldier shops I have visited there are Charlie Tarbox's Toy Soldiers and Gettysburg Miniature Toy Soldiers. The great thing is they are all on the same street - Steinwehr - less than 10 minutes walk between all three. I had never been to Tarbox before this previous trip. I just got into WWII and was exclusively into Civil War until a few months ago. Tarbox has nice displays and makes for more fun shopping. As far as selection, I think it is worth a trip to both Tarbox and Miniature Toy Soldiers. You might as well visit the American History Store too while you are at it, but you will find much more selection and WWII at the two toy soldier specialist shops. There is an antique mall in town with figures too, but I haven't been there in a while (I live in NC).