Gary,
No offense but apart from Albert, what do you have? Unless the Mets have no choice, in a big spot, with men in scoring position, they won't let Albert beat them. If we go position, what do you have:
Catcher - Mets
First Base - Cardinals (but not by much)
Second Base - Even
Shortstop - Mets (not even a contest here)
Third Base - Mets
Left Field - Cards
Center Field - Mets
Right Field - Mets
Starting Pitching - Probably even. However, Mets will probably be able to star Glavine three times whereas because you're using Carpenter today, he will be probably only start twice.
Bullpen - Mets have the best and the deepest pen in the NL.
There's a reason the Mets are the best team in the NL. You want to call in NY arrogance, so be it. We are the best team in the NL. The x factor is the Mets starting pitching. It's seriously weakened because of the loss of Pedro and El Duque. But for that it would be a shoo in. Mets in 6 but I'm hoping for 5.
Sorry, Gary, it just doesn't stack up for you guys, assuming you get in.