A Korean "Saving Private Ryan"??? (1 Viewer)

UKReb

Command Sergeant Major
Joined
Aug 31, 2007
Messages
2,436
I dont know if any of you guys have seen this or if it's even been discussed on these threads, apologies if it has but a pal of mine lent me a DVD some weeks ago called
The Brotherhood a Korean war film saying "Watch it it's as good as SPR".
Ho Hum! Yeah right on I thought (didn't want to upset him as he really is a good chum but his movie tastes are a world away from mine) so I just stowed it on my shelf and forgot about it as Asian films have never been on my radar screen and an Asian SPR!!!! Do me a favour please.

Last night with rain lashing down as per usual in the UK, lady partner at the gym, utter garbage on the TV channels, my miniature soldiers turned in for the night I headed for my DVD library. Right what's it to be, those magnificent beards of Gettysburg or George Scott as Patton? Er what's this? Oh yeah the Korean SPR, Oh! What the hell lets just chapter jump to whatever action scenes it's got. With a Jack Daniels and coke in hand and an anticipated boredom cloud about to descend on me I discd up.

Guys, I was absolutely blown away this is an amazing action packed and very moving cinema treat. I will not draw too many comparisons with SPR as far as I'm concerned that's a stand alone epic and using it as a comparator hardly does justice to the cultural differences between the films. Suffice to say that I can understand why others draw those conclusions; both films have a prologue and epilogue set in the present; hand held cameras; graphic and devastating battle scenes; unbelievable sound effects-my surround sound was working overtime dealing with explosions, falling debris and cries of the dying and wounded and I was almost ducking the bullets that were winging and ricochetting around my lounge.
The story briefly: two brothers are drafted into the South Korean army and with hardly any training are thrust into a major battle with the North. The older brother has tasked himself to protect his younger student sibling and intends to get him home by winning the medal that buys you a home-run ticket back. Subsequently he volunteers for every suicide mission to earn merits toward the medal only to discover he is a natural born leader and actually begins to enjoy killing the enemy. Swiftly moving up the ranks he continues to volunteer himself and his platoon for dangerous missions which in turn causes conflict between him and his kid brother due to other colleagues now having to give up their lives to gain his ticket back to Seoul.

Great story and a good sign for me has always been if I am still thinking about it the next day; a very moving soundtrack, and the most graphic and impressive battle set-ups I have seen since SPR- Hell I'm now almost drawing a comparison- but I'm in town tomorrow to get my own copy and I've seen the double disc version in the bargain bins for £3.00 ($6.00)
If you haven't caught this buy/rent a copy and prepare to be moved and I bet you five will get me ten that you'll be gripping your chair-arms during the mine-field scene.
Reb
 
Reb,
I've got this one. In Korean but with English sub-titles.
Absolutely brilliant movie.
Likewise, some of the stuff coming out of the Hong Kong studios these days is also pretty entertaining at a certain level, as long as you don't take them too seriously and as long as you can suspend disbelief during the majority of the "fight" sequences.

Cheers
H
 
Reb,
I've got this one. In Korean but with English sub-titles.
Absolutely brilliant movie.
Likewise, some of the stuff coming out of the Hong Kong studios these days is also pretty entertaining at a certain level, as long as you don't take them too seriously and as long as you can suspend disbelief during the majority of the "fight" sequences.

Cheers
H

Harry

Yet another topic we totally agree on. Well I'll go to the top of our stairs:D:D

Reb
 
Couldn't agree more Reb, a brilliant movie all around. If the ending doesn't get to you, you have no soul.................
 
I dont know if any of you guys have seen this or if it's even been discussed on these threads, apologies if it has but a pal of mine lent me a DVD some weeks ago called
The Brotherhood a Korean war film saying "Watch it it's as good as SPR".
...
Great story and a good sign for me has always been if I am still thinking about it the next day; a very moving soundtrack, and the most graphic and impressive battle set-ups I have seen since SPR- Hell I'm now almost drawing a comparison- but I'm in town tomorrow to get my own copy and I've seen the double disc version in the bargain bins for £3.00 ($6.00)
If you haven't caught this buy/rent a copy and prepare to be moved and I bet you five will get me ten that you'll be gripping your chair-arms during the mine-field scene.
Reb
Well I value your recommendations so I will definitely go and find this one.

Thanks for the heads up Reb.
 
Well I value your recommendations so I will definitely go and find this one.

Thanks for the heads up Reb.

Your very welcome old son and you wont regret it-However, If you do think it's a dud after watching it (and I'm positive you wont) I'll recompense you the cost of the DVD:eek::eek:
Now that's an offer you cant refuse but the Reb cannot afford a reputation of recommending duff war movies to his pals here on the forum:D:D

Reb
 
Reb - I agree, a superb, thought provoking movie with some great action scenes.
 
I just finished seeing this movie and thanks for another fine recommendation.
 
Watched it last night, some great battle scenes, the likes of SPR.
HOWEVER, way to many hand to hand fights, almost like those old kung fo movies.
George, I disagree, what a goofy, completely implausable ending.
The huge battle and the two brothers just happen to meet and fight one another, I,ll give movie makeing some creative license, but not this much!
Gary
 
Gary,
I meant the ending when the younger brother is called to the battlefield to view his brothers remains and he breaks down and starts crying and then they show his grandaughter crying as well.

That is the part I was referring to.

The assault on the city was about the best battle scene I've seen in a movie aside from the beginning and end of SPR, the assault on Nuenen and the attack on Cotentin in BOB....................
 
George, your right, that part reminded me of the old man at the graveyard in SPR.
The ending fight between the two brothers, with all the dark make up they had on, it made them both look like some vaudville actors in blackface!
Gary
 
I just liked the movie, the story was sort of hokey at times, but the theme where one brother is trying to do the right thing for other and in the end, the younger brother understands what the older brother was trying to do.

By that point, it was too late, sad on many levels.............
 
:eek:
Now you're just showing off:D:D:D
Esteemed Sir,I've fallen into the disreputable habit of reading threads backwards-i.e. click most recent post & prev,prev,prev...and somehow failed to notice the 1st page and your threadstarting entry-which would have clearly established this film's identity.I first saw it a couple of Summers ago during a Korean Film enthusiasm I was enjoying concurrent with a beer holiday.Consequently I've viewed it numerous times in various strata of awareness ,awoken to the disc menu theme cycling,popped open a McEwan's Scotch Ale from the case beside the bed & hit play.What I like about it is it's humanity,the undertones of Korean theatrical tradition,& the as-you-noted excellent soundtrack.On the feeling level I'd give it 5 stars.I CANNOT recommend HERE Chan Wook Park's Vengeance Trilogy,2 of which were out at the time.o.
 
"Tae Guk Gi"

Excellent impression of a drunk Scotsman instructing the taxi driver to take him home, Old Boy.
:D:D:D

Cheers
H
Thank god you were amused! I've known yankee boys to get rather bruised or worse doing such impressions.Might be best to save my a capella "Northern Lights of Old Aberdeen" for a less discriminating audience.Slainte,o.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top