You would hate to be looking for consistency in the press coverage of the Ashes. Australia was ready to steamroll a weak and dispirited England, then a revitalised England who had played exciting cricket against NZ was ready to take Australia down, then Mitchell Johnson was going to blow a weak England top order away, then England defeated an arrogant and complacent Australia and now with an Australian victory in the second Test we have come full circle. Can that much really have changed in a three week period? The journalists are really writing a narrative rather than trying to accurately assess what they are actually watching. If there is one lesson to be learnt, that surely is that no team is as good as we think and no team is as bad.
The standout was clearly Steve Smith but, it must be said, he does not possess a technique that will allow him to score runs easily when he is out of form like an Allan Border or a David Boon. That said, at present it is difficult to picture what an out of form Smith might look like.
Watson is finished. I like him but even if he scored ten centuries in the next 18 months he would still end his career as an underachiever given his prodigious talent.
Australia's pace bowling is strong.
The success of Rogers in a variety of conditions shows that years in the Shield and County Cricket make a man tough. Selection is not always about the 22 year olds.
Clarke is a worry but is still good enough if his body holds up but the sun must be setting on his career.
Ian Bell was once a stand out performer. He has been a wonderful cricketer but he is struggling.
The decision to make wickets batting friendly yet have both Tests finish in four days? Can no-one block anymore? Where is Boycott when you need him? Is Cook the only Englishman prepared to bat a full day for a hundred (or nearly?)
Good to see Australia win but there must be a couple of tough English qualified players the equivalent of Rogers who have the technique and the temperament to play Test cricket. Does anyone remember David Steele in 1975?
Jack