Most Popular Line (1 Viewer)

Most Popular Jenkins Line

  • Monongahela

    Votes: 11 29.7%
  • Plains of Abraham

    Votes: 5 13.5%
  • Battle on Snowshoes

    Votes: 12 32.4%
  • Raid on St. Francis

    Votes: 2 5.4%
  • Jacobites

    Votes: 6 16.2%
  • War of 1812

    Votes: 1 2.7%

  • Total voters
    37

Combat

Brigadier General
Joined
Jun 10, 2005
Messages
10,370
One last poll then my poll allotment is done for the year.
 
Snowshoe sets are my favorite although I had enough snow this winter. Leadmen
 
My favorite is now 1745 Jacobites but POA & Monongahela are right behind. -- lancer
 
I think the final tally will be like this:
1.Jacobites
2.Monongahela
3.BOS
4.POA
5.St.Francis
6.1812
I think St.Francis may move up to number 3 when more sets are released.
Mark
 
Not surprised by Monongahela leading but surprised by Jacobite showing so far after all the praising of the range.
Mark
 
Not surprised by Monongahela leading but surprised by Jacobite showing so far after all the praising of the range.
Mark

It's a relatively new line and there may be some US collectors who are not that interested in the historical context. I think it will gain in popularity as more figures come out and the word spreads about how good they are.
 
It's a relatively new line and there may be some US collectors who are not that interested in the historical context. I think it will gain in popularity as more figures come out and the word spreads about how good they are.
I agree with this. The 5 figures currently available may not be enough to garner "favorite" statis for many yet, but a little imagination and a few more figures will solve the question for many people. -- lancer
 
I voted for the Jacobites, this range could be really expanded greatly...maybe we'll have some building like a towerhouse or the Ruthven Barracks..and more British Infantry, militiamen, loyalist highlanders troops...
 
What surprises me a bit is how well BOS is doing and how few votes there are for POA. Maybe the POA vote is going to Monongahela. Also there haven't been many POA releases lately.
 
Actually there have been quite a few in the last 3-4 months.2 French Marine sets,The French artillery sets,the cavalry figure,3-4 British sets.I think these polls are good so John can see what the collecters really like and want.As I said before I think the 1812 range is the least popular.
Mark
 
IMO the POA series is a steal. All of the early issues are still available at issue price. The infantry for both sides are really good as are the Montcalm & Wolfe issues. The whole series is well done with many choices to pick from. If JJD had not done the Jacobites, POA would be my #1 choice, and for variety, it still is. I do not know if POA will shoot up in value when it sells out, but those who miss it will be sorry on general principle. -- lancer
 
I really don't know why historically the War of 1812 never interested me..but as i see is a common view (obviously my judgement is related to the toy soldier world and to this poll), there are elements to make it more interesting,maybe the addition of a "scene" as with Wolfe , Montcalm, Braddock could make it more palatable.... maybe the death of Pakenham (the brother in law of the Duke if i recall)!
 
I think it would do better if they started off with the Battle of New Orleans.I think this would be much more popular,especially with American collectors.Some American and Canadian militia would be nice.The War of 1812 has never been as popular in the U.S. as the Revolution or Civil War or even the French & Indian War.I do think the British sets are great.
Mark
 
Even though I'm a Snowshoes fan I'm quite surprised at it's showing against Monongahela.
Mark
 
The unparalleled artistic quality (both sculpting and painting) and the uniqeness of the subject matter make the Battle on Snowshoes and Jacobites tops in my opinion.
 
I don't know where is headed the Jacobite range (we'll have more jacobites regiments?surely we'll have Barrel's 4th Foot) , but the flagbearer i received showed me that this is (to my opinion) by far the best range of John Jenkins , and one of the best in toy soldier world!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top