As this was never really solved could they be Alymer? I just processed a set by them - "El Oasis" AB69 - where the trees have the same flat brass bases as these figures. Does anyone know if Alymer made figures with those kinds of bases as well???
Hi, Julie, possibly, but I can't yet confirm that they are or are not by Alymer.
The Alymer figures I have, have two types of base. One is a round piece of brass or copper, stamped, with "ALYMER Spain" stamped on the underside of the base. The other type is a square piece, cast in white metal, with a lip running around the outer edge, providing a little bit of height for a display base. On the underside of the base, "Alymer Spain" is incised.
Checking my references, I've run into my first disappointment with O'Brien, since I first bought his "Collecting Toy Soldiers", starting back in '89. There's no chapter on Alymer. I looked first in his 4th edition, "Collecting Foreign-Made Toy Soldiers", and the section on Spain consists of two pages of black-and-white photos of plastic figures. Then I went back to the second edition, the expanded "Collecting Toy Soldiers", and there's no mention there, either. On reflection, though, I can see that he excluded Alymer, because they're not toy soldiers for play, a la Britains, but they've always been considered as miniatures, in the same vein as Stadden, Imrie-Risley, et al.
I looked next in Garratt's "World Encyclopedia of Model Soldiers" for pictures, but that proved relatively inconclusive. He has photos of some Alymer figures, but the only ones that had rectangular tin bases were mounted. Garratt's article also lists the subjects Alymer produced, but it doesn't include US Civil War. Fortunately, Alymer is still in business today, and here is their website:
http://www.alymer.com/en/index.php
I found no US Civil War in the Toy Soldiers area, but in the catalog for Boxed Sets, they do have some sets:
Confederate Infantry:
http://www.alymer.com/1854-Infanteria-Confederada,-1862.html
Confederate Group (consisting of a color-bearer, a fifer and a drummer):
http://www.alymer.com/1910-1862-Grupo-de-confederados.html
Union Infantry:
http://www.alymer.com/1855-1862-United-Infantry.html
Union artillery (field piece, limber and team):
http://www.alymer.com/1904-Arrastre-de-artilleria-de-la-Union.html
Union field hospital:
http://www.alymer.com/1531-Union-Field-Hospital,-1862.html
Union artillery unit (field piece and crew):
http://www.alymer.com/1356-Union-Artillery-Unit.html
Confederate artillery unit (field piece and crew):
http://www.alymer.com/1357-Confederate-States-of-America-Artillery-Unit.html
and two Confederate field hospital sets:
http://www.alymer.com/1532-Confederate-States-of-America-Field-Hospital,-1862.html
http://www.alymer.com/1533-Confederate-States-of-America-Field-Hospital,-1862.html
Unfortunately, none of these sets contains figures like the ones you're trying to identify. It's not conclusive to say that they're not Alymer, but I think we're closer to confirming that they're not.
Now, as far as square tin bases and Spanish manufacturers go, Almiral used square tin bases, with rather sharp edges, but his figures were more robust, closer to 56mm or even 58mm, and as far as I know, he only made WWII German subjects.
I still think that your figures are of American make, and that they may even be something that a more talented painter put together. For one thing, I've never seen any makers who produced black Union soldiers, apart from Tom Loback's Thomas Tin Soldiers, who produced a set of 54th Massachusetts. That's not to say that there aren't, just that I'm not familiar with them.
Anyway, that's all I can come up with at this point.
Prost!
Brad