Roles that actors have declined or missed - what could have been. (1 Viewer)

The Military Workshop

1st Lieutenant
Joined
Jul 31, 2005
Messages
4,778
Hi Guys,
With Oscars coming thought it time for a movie thread.

Heard this subject being discussed on radio and had seen recent Tarantino interview where he mentioned Michael Madsen missing out on Pulp Fiction.

So here is a list of actors and roles they declined or missed. Anybody know any more.
Brett

Al Pacino
Turned down Richard Gere's role in Pretty Woman, saying the film was poorly written. Also, he wasn't interested in playing Han Solo, so he turned down Star Wars too.

Will Smith
The Wachowskis' first choice for the role of Neo in The Matrix. Will Smith found the script too hard to follow, but did later remark he found Keanu Reeves perfect for the role.

Mel Gibson
Was offered the role of Bruce Wayne/Batman in Tim Burton's 1989 adaptation. Mel Gibson thought the film would be a flop. ”

John Travolta Turned down the lead roles in Forrest Gump, Days Of Heaven and American Gigolo

Michelle Pfiffer
Turned down the role of Clarice Starling in Jonathan Demme's landmark adaptation of The Silence Of The Lambs, finding the film too violent, dark and disturbing. The role was played by Jodie Foster and arguably remains her best-remembered performance.

Denzel Washington
Turned down a part in David Fincher's Se7en, due to the film being too dark. He reportedly regretted his decision later on.

Bruce Willis
Turned down the chance to play a ghost husband opposite his then off-screen wife Demi Moore in, well, Ghost

Kim BasingerTurned down the role of Catherine Tramell in Paul Verhoeven's thriller Basic Instinct. If she hadn't, Sharon Stone might have never gotten her break

Sean Connery
Turned down the role of Gandalf in Peter Jackson's adaptation of The Lord Of The Rings, due to him not "getting" fantasy. He cited the film's success as his reason to do his critically-panned final film, The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Sandra BullockLeft the role of Maggie Fitzgerald in Clint Eastwood's sports drama Million Dollar baby due to production delays. Replacing actress Hilary Swank won her second Oscar for the role, and Sandra Bullock starred in Miss Congeniality 2: Armed & Fabulous. ”

Jeremy Irons
Jonathan Demme wanted him to play Hanibal Lecter in his celebrated adaptation of The Silence of The Lambs, but Jeremy Irons found the script to be too violent. The part instead became the defining role of Anthony Hopkins' career.

Warren Beatty
If Warren Beatty had accepted to play the part of Michael Corleone in Francis Ford Coppola's gangster classic The Godfather, Al Pacino, whose first film role it became, might have never had a career in film.

Julia Roberts
Julia Roberts could have won her second Oscar if she hadn't turned down the part that eventually went to Sandra Bullock in The Blind Side, in order to do Valentine's Day. However, Roberts couldn't really say no to Valentine's Day director Garry Marshall, who gave her her big break in Pretty Woman, could she?

Tom Selleck
This actually isn't a case of an actor turning down a role, as Selleck was very interested, rather than one of an acotr not being allowed to play a part. Steven Spielberg and George Lucas both wanted Selleck to play Indiana Jones, but a deal couldn't be negotiated with Universal Studios, with whom Selleck had just signed to star in Magnum, P.I. Had Selleck been allowed to play the part, Harrison Ford, who George Lucas was reluctant to cast and who thus wouldn't have had another strong popular role following Star Wars, might just have gone the way of Mark Hamill and Carrie Fisher. As for Tom Selleck, he eventually starred in his own Indiana Jones-type film, the little-known, hard-to-find, but absolutely-worth-the-watch High Road To China. Interestingly the same situation came very close to happening with Michael J. Fox and his Back To The Future role, but a deal was eventually reached between studios

Halle Berry
Halle Berry turned down the role of bus driver Annie Porter opposite Keanu Reeves in the hit thriller Speed. The role went to Sandra Bullock and instantly cemented her status as one of America's most popular actresses. In the meantime, while Halle Berry did get fairly regular work, she had to wait another six years for her ball to really get rolling.

Edward NortonRelatively early on in his career, Norton turned down the titular role in Steven Spielberg's landmark war film Saving Private Ryan. The role eventually went to Matt Damon, an actor who back then had gotten noticed in more independent films and who was propelled into the big time thanks to this part,

Michael Madsen
Madsen and director Quentin Tarantino have collaborated numerous times. Twice strictly speaking, buth thrice if you count Kill Bill as 2 films and five times if you count Sin City and Hell Ride. As such it should come as no surprise that Tarantino had a role ready for Madsen in what remains his most famous film, Pulp Fiction. However Madsen was stuck with rehearsals for the western Wyatt Earp, and regularly expresses regret at not having played the part that was eventually renamed Vincent Vega, rewritten as a brother to Madsen's character Vic Vega from Reservoir Dogs, and given to John Travolta who, if Madsen had not been available, might never have enjoyed a much-needed carrer resurrection. ”

Jake Gyllenhaal
Hollywood experienced a Sam Worthington boom starting in 2009 with Terminator Salvation, Avatar and Clash Of The Titans, however the Australian actor may never have gotten his American dream if Jake Gyllenhaal hadn't turned down the Jake Sully role in Avatar.

Henry Winkler
Turned down the male lead in Grease, which famously went to John Travolta

Tom Hanks
Tom Hanks might be one of the most loved actors of this day and age but he could have added another feather to his cap had he not turned down the lead role in Field Of Dreams, now instead regarded as one of Kevin Costner's finest films.
 
Some really interesting facts in this post. I can see Madsen as Vincent Vega with no problem, or Irons as Hannibal Lecter. That would have been a good fit. Even Selleck as Indiana Jones. Pacino in Pretty Woman? Not so much. He is no where near as pretty as Gere, or Roberts, for that matter.:rolleyes2:^&grin -- Al
 
Lee Marvin

He was originally cast as Pike Bishop in The Wild Bunch (1969), but fell out with director Sam Peckinpah and pulled out in order to star in the Western musical Paint Your Wagon (1969).Despite his limited singing ability he had a hit song with "Wand'rin' Star".

William Holden played Pike Bishop in the movie.

Cheers

Martyn:)
 
Interesting stuff Brett. I think Selleck could have done it. He was really good in his Magnum PI series and I assume that's what attracted directors.
 
Hi Guys,
With Oscars coming thought it time for a movie thread.

Heard this subject being discussed on radio and had seen recent Tarantino interview where he mentioned Michael Madsen missing out on Pulp Fiction.

So here is a list of actors and roles they declined or missed. Anybody know any more.
Brett

Al Pacino
Turned down Richard Gere's role in Pretty Woman, saying the film was poorly written. Also, he wasn't interested in playing Han Solo, so he turned down Star Wars too.

Will Smith
The Wachowskis' first choice for the role of Neo in The Matrix. Will Smith found the script too hard to follow, but did later remark he found Keanu Reeves perfect for the role.

Mel Gibson
Was offered the role of Bruce Wayne/Batman in Tim Burton's 1989 adaptation. Mel Gibson thought the film would be a flop. ”

John Travolta Turned down the lead roles in Forrest Gump, Days Of Heaven and American Gigolo

Michelle Pfiffer
Turned down the role of Clarice Starling in Jonathan Demme's landmark adaptation of The Silence Of The Lambs, finding the film too violent, dark and disturbing. The role was played by Jodie Foster and arguably remains her best-remembered performance.

Denzel Washington
Turned down a part in David Fincher's Se7en, due to the film being too dark. He reportedly regretted his decision later on.

Bruce Willis
Turned down the chance to play a ghost husband opposite his then off-screen wife Demi Moore in, well, Ghost

Kim BasingerTurned down the role of Catherine Tramell in Paul Verhoeven's thriller Basic Instinct. If she hadn't, Sharon Stone might have never gotten her break

Sean Connery
Turned down the role of Gandalf in Peter Jackson's adaptation of The Lord Of The Rings, due to him not "getting" fantasy. He cited the film's success as his reason to do his critically-panned final film, The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Sandra BullockLeft the role of Maggie Fitzgerald in Clint Eastwood's sports drama Million Dollar baby due to production delays. Replacing actress Hilary Swank won her second Oscar for the role, and Sandra Bullock starred in Miss Congeniality 2: Armed & Fabulous. ”

Jeremy Irons
Jonathan Demme wanted him to play Hanibal Lecter in his celebrated adaptation of The Silence of The Lambs, but Jeremy Irons found the script to be too violent. The part instead became the defining role of Anthony Hopkins' career.

Warren Beatty
If Warren Beatty had accepted to play the part of Michael Corleone in Francis Ford Coppola's gangster classic The Godfather, Al Pacino, whose first film role it became, might have never had a career in film.

Julia Roberts
Julia Roberts could have won her second Oscar if she hadn't turned down the part that eventually went to Sandra Bullock in The Blind Side, in order to do Valentine's Day. However, Roberts couldn't really say no to Valentine's Day director Garry Marshall, who gave her her big break in Pretty Woman, could she?

Tom Selleck
This actually isn't a case of an actor turning down a role, as Selleck was very interested, rather than one of an acotr not being allowed to play a part. Steven Spielberg and George Lucas both wanted Selleck to play Indiana Jones, but a deal couldn't be negotiated with Universal Studios, with whom Selleck had just signed to star in Magnum, P.I. Had Selleck been allowed to play the part, Harrison Ford, who George Lucas was reluctant to cast and who thus wouldn't have had another strong popular role following Star Wars, might just have gone the way of Mark Hamill and Carrie Fisher. As for Tom Selleck, he eventually starred in his own Indiana Jones-type film, the little-known, hard-to-find, but absolutely-worth-the-watch High Road To China. Interestingly the same situation came very close to happening with Michael J. Fox and his Back To The Future role, but a deal was eventually reached between studios

Halle Berry
Halle Berry turned down the role of bus driver Annie Porter opposite Keanu Reeves in the hit thriller Speed. The role went to Sandra Bullock and instantly cemented her status as one of America's most popular actresses. In the meantime, while Halle Berry did get fairly regular work, she had to wait another six years for her ball to really get rolling.

Edward NortonRelatively early on in his career, Norton turned down the titular role in Steven Spielberg's landmark war film Saving Private Ryan. The role eventually went to Matt Damon, an actor who back then had gotten noticed in more independent films and who was propelled into the big time thanks to this part,

Michael Madsen
Madsen and director Quentin Tarantino have collaborated numerous times. Twice strictly speaking, buth thrice if you count Kill Bill as 2 films and five times if you count Sin City and Hell Ride. As such it should come as no surprise that Tarantino had a role ready for Madsen in what remains his most famous film, Pulp Fiction. However Madsen was stuck with rehearsals for the western Wyatt Earp, and regularly expresses regret at not having played the part that was eventually renamed Vincent Vega, rewritten as a brother to Madsen's character Vic Vega from Reservoir Dogs, and given to John Travolta who, if Madsen had not been available, might never have enjoyed a much-needed carrer resurrection. ”

Jake Gyllenhaal
Hollywood experienced a Sam Worthington boom starting in 2009 with Terminator Salvation, Avatar and Clash Of The Titans, however the Australian actor may never have gotten his American dream if Jake Gyllenhaal hadn't turned down the Jake Sully role in Avatar.

Henry Winkler
Turned down the male lead in Grease, which famously went to John Travolta

Tom Hanks
Tom Hanks might be one of the most loved actors of this day and age but he could have added another feather to his cap had he not turned down the lead role in Field Of Dreams, now instead regarded as one of Kevin Costner's finest films.
High Rd to China.....one of the best movie's made... Have DVD after many yrs of searching...Tom Selleck was a natural...would have been okay in Star Wars and a lot of other movies....saw him recently in a cowboy movie...cannot remember name...good Selleck movie as usual...cheers TomB
 
High Rd to China.....one of the best movie's made... Have DVD after many yrs of searching...Tom Selleck was a natural...would have been okay in Star Wars and a lot of other movies....saw him recently in a cowboy movie...cannot remember name...good Selleck movie as usual...cheers TomB
Tom: Interesting. Also, consider George C Scott as Patton. John Wayne, Burt Lancaster and Charlton Heston either turned it down or were otherwise committed. Great book "Making Patton" by Nicholas Sarantakes. The movie was in the works for 18 years. Tom Selleck was terrific in "Quigley Down Under". Tommy
 
George C. Scott received the role in "Patton" after John Wayne, Burt Lancaster, Charlton Heston and others turned it down or were otherwise committed. Interesting read "Making Patton" by Nicholas Sarantakes. Also, one of my favorites is Tom Selleck in "Quigley Down Under". Tommy
 
Tom: Interesting. Also, consider George C Scott as Patton. John Wayne, Burt Lancaster and Charlton Heston either turned it down or were otherwise committed. Great book "Making Patton" by Nicholas Sarantakes. The movie was in the works for 18 years. Tom Selleck was terrific in "Quigley Down Under". Tommy
George C Scott was the only choice....could not imagine Patton in Roman Robes or a cowboy outfit....Burt was okay but not his style.....Have seen a few duco's on Patton.....I reserve my opinion of him....it has been suggested he was " Knocked Off" when he started investigating Black Marketing...though that would have been in the book.....Quigley Down Under...I started to watch it,,,But,,,there was too much Australianlization in it and I could not hack it....I reckon Tom Selleck would have been embarrassed making it... cheers TomB
 
Hi Guys,
With Oscars coming thought it time for a movie thread.

Heard this subject being discussed on radio and had seen recent Tarantino interview where he mentioned Michael Madsen missing out on Pulp Fiction.

So here is a list of actors and roles they declined or missed. Anybody know any more.
Brett

Al Pacino
Turned down Richard Gere's role in Pretty Woman, saying the film was poorly written. Also, he wasn't interested in playing Han Solo, so he turned down Star Wars too.

Will Smith
The Wachowskis' first choice for the role of Neo in The Matrix. Will Smith found the script too hard to follow, but did later remark he found Keanu Reeves perfect for the role.

Mel Gibson
Was offered the role of Bruce Wayne/Batman in Tim Burton's 1989 adaptation. Mel Gibson thought the film would be a flop. ”

John Travolta Turned down the lead roles in Forrest Gump, Days Of Heaven and American Gigolo

Michelle Pfiffer
Turned down the role of Clarice Starling in Jonathan Demme's landmark adaptation of The Silence Of The Lambs, finding the film too violent, dark and disturbing. The role was played by Jodie Foster and arguably remains her best-remembered performance.

Denzel Washington
Turned down a part in David Fincher's Se7en, due to the film being too dark. He reportedly regretted his decision later on.

Bruce Willis
Turned down the chance to play a ghost husband opposite his then off-screen wife Demi Moore in, well, Ghost

Kim BasingerTurned down the role of Catherine Tramell in Paul Verhoeven's thriller Basic Instinct. If she hadn't, Sharon Stone might have never gotten her break

Sean Connery
Turned down the role of Gandalf in Peter Jackson's adaptation of The Lord Of The Rings, due to him not "getting" fantasy. He cited the film's success as his reason to do his critically-panned final film, The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Sandra BullockLeft the role of Maggie Fitzgerald in Clint Eastwood's sports drama Million Dollar baby due to production delays. Replacing actress Hilary Swank won her second Oscar for the role, and Sandra Bullock starred in Miss Congeniality 2: Armed & Fabulous. ”

Jeremy Irons
Jonathan Demme wanted him to play Hanibal Lecter in his celebrated adaptation of The Silence of The Lambs, but Jeremy Irons found the script to be too violent. The part instead became the defining role of Anthony Hopkins' career.

Warren Beatty
If Warren Beatty had accepted to play the part of Michael Corleone in Francis Ford Coppola's gangster classic The Godfather, Al Pacino, whose first film role it became, might have never had a career in film.

Julia Roberts
Julia Roberts could have won her second Oscar if she hadn't turned down the part that eventually went to Sandra Bullock in The Blind Side, in order to do Valentine's Day. However, Roberts couldn't really say no to Valentine's Day director Garry Marshall, who gave her her big break in Pretty Woman, could she?

Tom Selleck
This actually isn't a case of an actor turning down a role, as Selleck was very interested, rather than one of an acotr not being allowed to play a part. Steven Spielberg and George Lucas both wanted Selleck to play Indiana Jones, but a deal couldn't be negotiated with Universal Studios, with whom Selleck had just signed to star in Magnum, P.I. Had Selleck been allowed to play the part, Harrison Ford, who George Lucas was reluctant to cast and who thus wouldn't have had another strong popular role following Star Wars, might just have gone the way of Mark Hamill and Carrie Fisher. As for Tom Selleck, he eventually starred in his own Indiana Jones-type film, the little-known, hard-to-find, but absolutely-worth-the-watch High Road To China. Interestingly the same situation came very close to happening with Michael J. Fox and his Back To The Future role, but a deal was eventually reached between studios

Halle Berry
Halle Berry turned down the role of bus driver Annie Porter opposite Keanu Reeves in the hit thriller Speed. The role went to Sandra Bullock and instantly cemented her status as one of America's most popular actresses. In the meantime, while Halle Berry did get fairly regular work, she had to wait another six years for her ball to really get rolling.

Edward NortonRelatively early on in his career, Norton turned down the titular role in Steven Spielberg's landmark war film Saving Private Ryan. The role eventually went to Matt Damon, an actor who back then had gotten noticed in more independent films and who was propelled into the big time thanks to this part,

Michael Madsen
Madsen and director Quentin Tarantino have collaborated numerous times. Twice strictly speaking, buth thrice if you count Kill Bill as 2 films and five times if you count Sin City and Hell Ride. As such it should come as no surprise that Tarantino had a role ready for Madsen in what remains his most famous film, Pulp Fiction. However Madsen was stuck with rehearsals for the western Wyatt Earp, and regularly expresses regret at not having played the part that was eventually renamed Vincent Vega, rewritten as a brother to Madsen's character Vic Vega from Reservoir Dogs, and given to John Travolta who, if Madsen had not been available, might never have enjoyed a much-needed carrer resurrection. ”

Jake Gyllenhaal
Hollywood experienced a Sam Worthington boom starting in 2009 with Terminator Salvation, Avatar and Clash Of The Titans, however the Australian actor may never have gotten his American dream if Jake Gyllenhaal hadn't turned down the Jake Sully role in Avatar.

Henry Winkler
Turned down the male lead in Grease, which famously went to John Travolta

Tom Hanks
Tom Hanks might be one of the most loved actors of this day and age but he could have added another feather to his cap had he not turned down the lead role in Field Of Dreams, now instead regarded as one of Kevin Costner's finest films.

Interesting post. It is funny to me how many of those star choices were correct for the movie.

Pacino is the better actor but Gere was a much better choice for Pretty Women.

Smith is also the better actor but Reeves nailed the part of Neo.

Gibson would not have been a very good Batman, which ironically and contrary to expectations, Michael Keaton very much was.

Travolta would have been poor casting for Forest Gump, shame on the studio for thinking that.

Foster was a much better choice for SotL

I don't blame Denzel at all for Se7en, it was too bloody dark.

Willis as the simpering Ghost husband, I think not.

Stone's beauty was pushing the limits of credibility as it was for that role, Basinger's, though she could have managed the part well enough, would have been over the top.

Sir Sean as Gandalf, just not right for him really, as good as he is.

Bullock was totally wrong for Million Dollar Baby. It is lucky for both it went to Swank since Bullock would not have even gotten a nomination in this part.
SotL was just not right for Irons, but near perfect for Hopkins. That said, I care little for the movie and I certainly hope it was not Hopkins defining film.

I think Pacino was destined for a film success no matter with or without this role. It was the 1971 film The Panic in Needle that actually assured his career. No doubt this helped him and he was a much better choice than Beatty for that role.

Roberts/Bullock, this is the only one I think would have gone either way. Both could have been brilliant in the role.

I love Selleck and I think he would have been a great, but different Indy. Maybe I love the movies as they are too much but I think Harrison was actually the better choice. Quigley is one of my most watched films but currently though, I eagarly await each new Jessie Stone TV movie for which he is producer, writer and star. The is a Blu-ray release for High Road to China but it is not a great transfer. I may still get it since it has to be better than the crap DVD version.

Berry would have been quite wrong for Speed, the character was not to her style.

Norton is a great actor but his type would have been all wrong for the SPR Damon role.

The Pulp Fiction character played by Travolta brought out the best in his acting. It is the type he excells at. Madsen was lucky not to get the role since Jackson then really would have stolen the show.

Worthington was a much better choice for Avatar.

Travolta versus Winkler, no contest.

Field of Dreams was well suited to Costner, it would not have been for Hanks, no matter how good he is.
 
Last edited:
'High Road to China' is indeed an under-rated movie while I seem to remember Paul Hogan being considered for the role in 'Ghost'.

I suppose its all hit and miss. There would be many movies that these actors would regret choosing. Sometimes it is about luck. I cannot imagine the script for Star Wars looking all that impressive at first look but in the cinema it was great entertainment.

As for Julia Roberts - I am going to report every post that says a movie she starred in as worth the money on the grounds that it is argumentative. Awful...just awful.
 
Another thing to remember is that these guys ( and gals) just read out loud the words that other people write - and then go home.

I believe that Sir Laurence Olivier said something to that effect - when asked by a reporter about some role or other he had starred in. I was rather pleased reading that he once said that. Helps to keep feet on the ground - things like that.

They are all actors, after all - doing a job. jb
 
Another thing to remember is that these guys ( and gals) just read out loud the words that other people write - and then go home.

I believe that Sir Laurence Olivier said something to that effect - when asked by a reporter about some role or other he had starred in. I was rather pleased reading that he once said that. Helps to keep feet on the ground - things like that.

They are all actors, after all - doing a job. jb

They may be doing a job but just like any job, some are brilliant some shouldn't even get before the camera, with many levels in between. There is a big difference between reading the words aloud and being an actor. To understand that all one need do is compare many of the current generation of actors to those that came before them. In some cases no words can save them. A great writer can make a good actor look better but he can not make a bad actor look good.
 
'High Road to China' is indeed an under-rated movie while I seem to remember Paul Hogan being considered for the role in 'Ghost'.

I suppose its all hit and miss. There would be many movies that these actors would regret choosing. Sometimes it is about luck. I cannot imagine the script for Star Wars looking all that impressive at first look but in the cinema it was great entertainment.

As for Julia Roberts - I am going to report every post that says a movie she starred in as worth the money on the grounds that it is argumentative. Awful...just awful.

Does this mean you are declaring war on Julia Roberts fans ? People need to be warned about the impending "hostilities"{sm4}.

I am guessing Pretty Woman not yet in your DVD collection.
 
Tom Cruise turned down WALL STREET which went to Charlie Sheen......I think Tom made a mistake there.
But Sheen pulled it off anyway!
 
Great thread Brett .Couple of films Steve McQueen turn down are Apocalypse now and Rambo first blood which I think he would of been great in both
 
Great thread Brett .Couple of films Steve McQueen turn down are Apocalypse now and Rambo first blood which I think he would of been great in both

Believe it or not I only just saw Bullit for first time 2 nights ago !{sm2} A young Jacqueline Bisset in that one and she reminded me of Liz Hurley.
 
Jack,
The President of the Julia Roberts Fan Club called. Dont worry you are safe as I gave them the immortal line "I dont know Jack ....".^&grin
Brett
 
Does this mean you are declaring war on Julia Roberts fans ? People need to be warned about the impending "hostilities"{sm4}.

Not so much a war as a limited police action with identifiable aims!

Not everyone can be an Alison Brie or Jane Seymor I suppose!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top