Totally there were 22 entries in the competition by 13 people. The breakdown was as follows :
Medieval (KC) - Mark IV - Judges 3rd Choice
Saracen Oasis (KC) - Sapper
American War of Independence Ambush (KC) - Farmer Tony - Won Andy's First Choice
Jacobite Rebellion (JJ) - Farmer Tony
Indian prisoners with canoe (JJ)
Indians in canoe (JJ) - Sapper
Nelsons Navy (mix KC, JJ guns and Forward March) - Judges 2nd Choice
Gallipoli trench (mix JJ/KC) - Won Andy's 3rd Choice
Western Front trench (mix JJ/KC) - Won Peoples Choice and Andy's 2nd Choice
Trench WWI (no figures)
French WWI (JJ) - Mark IV
Berlin Parade (KC with conversions of the flags) - forum member Ray - won Peoples Choice 2nd
Blitz (KC) by lady collector Carole
German Snow Patrol (KC) - Won Judges First Choice
GI Foxholes Bulge (KC) - Mark IV
D Day Sherman on beach (KC) - Jack
Afrika Korps (KC) - Mark IV
SS Kubelwagen (KC)
Stalingrad (KC)
Japanese attack TG - Mark IV
Japanese v Aussies in box TG
Japanese Jungle patrol TG
The following entries were by the same person :
Western Front trench (mix JJ/KC) - Won Peoples Choice and Andy's 2nd Choice
German Snow Patrol (KC) - Won Judges First Choice and Peoples Choice 3rd
and he also did the Japanese jungle patrol.
But wait there is more. His son also won the K&C Normandy Quad and limber in the lucky draw.
The judging was very difficult.
Basically we had Bob and Wayne judging their 1st, 2nd and 3rd Choices. It was mentioned by them that the winning dio's (Bulge German snow patrol) grass might have been a bit too green but the inside and outside elements in the one small dio made this one their first pick. (Please not the dios were set up just before the dinner so many would not have their bases covered as figures were place on base at set up).
People's Choice was based on votes by all who attended. There is a photo of winner in thread already and I have another to come that is probably not as good as Waynes. I am trying to see if any more good ones available. It was the trench and mud detail that made this one stand out.
Andy's Choice was entirely his own decision and I know Andy had a problem with picking. He picked the AWI Ambush by FarmerTony. His 2nd and 3rd Choices (Western Front and Gallipoli) included Jenkins figures.
Not that my vote counted any more than others but on Peoples Choice I also happened to vote for the winner.
As in previous years Jack organised the dinner aspects of the event and use of the Museum and did some MC ing. He even manned the bar and made a joke at my expense about me having
just said I was not good at telling jokes{sm2}. As always he was ably assisted by his wonderful wife and I am still getting grief from my wife for not thanking Jacks wife during the event. Heartfelt thanks go to both of them as a lot of work involved behind the scenes. Jack now much busier at work than previous years so for him to give up so much of his time is much appreciated by all the local collectors and myself. On a side note he also presented Andy with a book he has had published (I guess Dr Dr's need more than one hobby:salute:
.
Special mention must go to Wayne and Bob. Some may recall Wayne's arrival on the forum a few years ago. He started putting up lots of great little dios and his backdrop work became well known. I think we can "blame" him for the K&C Diorama section of the forum as he was so prolific. This spread to a few of the other local collectors and many have seen his work over the years. Bob has also been big on dios and created some to show in the shop so people could see what they could fit in the space available for the competition. The competition was his idea and it exceeded our expectations in terms of entrants, variety and quality. Thanks go to both of them and in particular for their encouragement of others (I have already had indications from four others who attended the dinner that they intend to enter the competition next year).
Thanks also to long time supporter of the dios, Glenn, for taking the pics and Mark IV for his five entries. Mark got a "Mentioned in Despatches" (but no medal) from Andy for his GI's in Foxholes.
Some may recall Firebat and his excellent diorama work shown here a few years ago. He was very much interested in trying to get modellers to cross over to this hobby. Being a talented modeller he would have no problem converting a tank or figure by painting or weathering it. They looked fantastic but probably not something many collectors are going to want to do to their metal figures or polystone / resin vehicles. However having fun with the building of a base to put them on is hopefully an aspect that might interest some collectors so that their hobby becomes a bit more than just collecting.
One minor point of interest. Andy was in the shop for a short while. A relatively new collector came in with his son in law and his three grand sons (aged about 9-12). The collector left them alone to look around whilst he talked to Andy. Next thing he knows he has four family members who also now own toy soldier owners as his son in law and 3 kids got some each (two Custer Indians, a Henry V and two WW2 Russians). What was good was the kids did seem to know a bit of history and knew what they were looking at.
Three of the entered dioramas were TG Japanese series so will have them put in TG area of forum. Same for the four Jenkins dios.
Normally I would have expected some Britains Zulu dioramas to have been entered. However since some had combined to create a large Zulu diorama or knew about it this may have affected their interest in doing smaller Zulu ones.
Come back over the next few days as more pics to come.