Ice station zebra (2 Viewers)
- Thread starter blaster
- Start date
Horus
Major General
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2015
- Messages
- 13,496
Wow Victor, we have different opinions. To me it's a very memorable film and I must of watched it half a dozen times over the years.
Patrick McGoohan was certainly typecast, following on from his iconic TV rolls in Dangerman (Secret Agent) and The Prisoner, pretty much rehashing his rolls, though I'm sure others will disagree.
blaster
Major
- Joined
- Sep 10, 2008
- Messages
- 6,297
Hello Steve and jomatyr
I did try to like it. Esp it being one of those classic oldies. I practically grew up in a movie theatre house. My auntie was part owner mgr of it and I watched thousands of oldies for free. I remember watching ISZ but couldn’t remember the plot except for a sub, arctic snow and rock Hudson. Hahaha
So let me share with y my 2nd viewing of it.
This is Cold War stuff so I was expecting US vs USSR skullduggery.
Rock Hudson is the sub Capt tasked with ferrying spyPatrick McGoohan to ISZ. But it’s all hush hush. Along the way they helicopter in a bunch of marines led by Jim Brown and Ernest Borgnine ex Russian spy. Along the way someone tries to sabotage the sub. But who dun it? Patrick McG master spy says it is Jim Brown as he will vouch for Ernest Borg anytime.
ISZ turns out to be completely gutted and sabotaged by some convoluted spy vs spy kill off typical of Mad magazine.
Ernest Borg turns out to be really a non reformed Russian spy and poor Jim Brown is mistakenly killed off by P McG. Later P McG kills Ernest Borg.
Then the Russian paratroopers drop in. Both sides shoot off a load of automated smgs at each other and there are NO casualties!!! One young marine then tries to do a heroic act of assaulting the Russian cdr and is wounded. All this while, Rock Hudson stands tall to one side and has a few lines.
Whatever nostalgia I may have had for this movie is gone forever.
Rgds Vic.
I did try to like it. Esp it being one of those classic oldies. I practically grew up in a movie theatre house. My auntie was part owner mgr of it and I watched thousands of oldies for free. I remember watching ISZ but couldn’t remember the plot except for a sub, arctic snow and rock Hudson. Hahaha
So let me share with y my 2nd viewing of it.
This is Cold War stuff so I was expecting US vs USSR skullduggery.
Rock Hudson is the sub Capt tasked with ferrying spyPatrick McGoohan to ISZ. But it’s all hush hush. Along the way they helicopter in a bunch of marines led by Jim Brown and Ernest Borgnine ex Russian spy. Along the way someone tries to sabotage the sub. But who dun it? Patrick McG master spy says it is Jim Brown as he will vouch for Ernest Borg anytime.
ISZ turns out to be completely gutted and sabotaged by some convoluted spy vs spy kill off typical of Mad magazine.
Ernest Borg turns out to be really a non reformed Russian spy and poor Jim Brown is mistakenly killed off by P McG. Later P McG kills Ernest Borg.
Then the Russian paratroopers drop in. Both sides shoot off a load of automated smgs at each other and there are NO casualties!!! One young marine then tries to do a heroic act of assaulting the Russian cdr and is wounded. All this while, Rock Hudson stands tall to one side and has a few lines.
Whatever nostalgia I may have had for this movie is gone forever.
Rgds Vic.
Horus
Major General
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2015
- Messages
- 13,496
Nice summary Victor and sounds like you had a fun time at the cinema in your youth.
Perhaps the magic of the old films at least for ISZ, is lost to you, though I'm sure others will still retain their charm for you.
Many of us have attachments to particular old films, often because of the remembrance of the person we saw it with, who may no longer be with us.
Perhaps the magic of the old films at least for ISZ, is lost to you, though I'm sure others will still retain their charm for you.
Many of us have attachments to particular old films, often because of the remembrance of the person we saw it with, who may no longer be with us.
panda1gen
Lieutenant Colonel
- Joined
- Jul 29, 2005
- Messages
- 7,013
I thought this film was ok on its own, but having read most of Alistair Maclean's books, I was very disappointed in the 'movie spin off plot' compared to the quality of his plots.
blaster
Major
- Joined
- Sep 10, 2008
- Messages
- 6,297
BobZ
Private 2
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2009
- Messages
- 112
The one thing I remember about this movie (and drives me nuts) is in the shot of the Russian fighters approaching they are MIG21s. But when they fly over they are F4 Phantoms. Apparently, the Russians invented F4 disguise kits.
BTW, Borgnine is not killed, only wounded. His fate is not provided, although I doubt it would turn out good.
BTW, Borgnine is not killed, only wounded. His fate is not provided, although I doubt it would turn out good.
Horus
Major General
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2015
- Messages
- 13,496
Yes, that's the drawback to watching a film adaptation of a popular book and I'm sure we could all name a few !
Horus
Major General
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2015
- Messages
- 13,496
Actually, no, not on ISZ, but others certainly. Such as Kelly's Heroes !
Louis Badolato
Lieutenant General
- Joined
- Apr 25, 2005
- Messages
- 17,928
I watched the Guns of Navarone with my son last night (his first viewing, and he loved it). Now that was a great Allister MacLean movie! Gregory Peck, Anthony Quinn, David Niven (the only casting choice that didn't match the book, Dusty Miller was supposed to by a tough mining explosive expert from Nevada, but it still worked). I was so disappointed by Force 10 from Navarone (despite the fact that the screen play was revamped by George MacDonald Frasier, my favorite author). Harrison Ford and Carl Weathers just couldn't save that terrible movie, which barely acknowledged the book.
panda1gen
Lieutenant Colonel
- Joined
- Jul 29, 2005
- Messages
- 7,013
What a well argued argument Louis, too right. Anthony Hopkins in 'When 8 Bells Toll' was a very good Alistair MacLean film though IMO.
Being an old g~t, I still remember the shear excitement as a kid going with my family to see these films at the cinema, especially the Battle of Britain, Guns of Navarone, Battle of the Bulge, Patton and Kelly's Heroes just to name a few.
As a kid I wasn't as critical of all the vehicles being ex USA or a rubbish plot, but now?
Full kudos to films like 'Fury', using more realistic and authentic kit.
Louis Badolato
Lieutenant General
- Joined
- Apr 25, 2005
- Messages
- 17,928
Kevin,
Great points, but I have to respectfully disagree with regard to Kelly's Heroes. I thought that, for the time, they did a great job reproducing the German vehicles, re-sheet-metaling Czech T34's into nice reproductions of tigers, re-sheet-metaling M3 Halftracks into Hanomags (which were spot on except for the tracks and bogie wheels), and getting real Opel Blitz trucks and Kubelwagons. The U.S. vehicles were all authentic, with the exception of using what looked like a T6 Harvard trainer to replicate a P47 Thunderbolt. But I agree, for the most part, hollywood used old American tanks painted gray with crosses on the turrets in making WWII movies until around the time of Saving Private Ryan.