Star Trek v Star Wars (2 Viewers)

Your Sci-Fi Favourite?


  • Total voters
    41
Starship Troopers. Classic stuff. Surprised it wasn't Oscar nominated. :)

Have to admit Starship troopers is imo a classic. and surpisingly was oscar nominated for Visual Effects, the director grew up in wartime german occupied holland and you get a hint of that era thru the use of propaganda, uniforms, flags and banners. The sequels were dire and unwatchable but the first film is ace .

Join the Mobile Infantry and save the Galaxy. Service guarantees citizenship. Would you like to know more? :D
 
They are all similar and god awful bad. Not good bad like the 50's sci fi movies, just bad.

Exactly, if they were entered into a film contest, they would win for comedy, not horror:eek::eek::eek::eek:!!!!! And in the film SuperGator, if you look when they actually show the gators snout up close, it looks like a pit bull without any hair eating the person:eek::D:eek: Does Jurassic Park count as a Sci-Fi genre?:confused::confused:

Vick
 
Does Buffy the Vampire Slayer count?.Eliza Dushku made me realise i'd like to have Faith;)

Rob
 
Does Jurassic Park count as a Sci-Fi genre?:confused::confused:

Vick

Yes, and there's another one that was a disappointment for me, having read the novel when it first came out.

I remember reading the book-another one that I read straight through in the space of a day, like other Crichton novels I've read-and thinking, "Boy, this would be a great movie, if only someone could figure out how to animate the dinosaurs realistically". The novel's themes are compelling.

Then Spielberg produced the movie. The special effects were astounding, raising the bar for all movies that followed. But he changed the story and several of the characters, in a way that ruin the story. Instead of being a cautionary tale about messing with things without trying to understand them, it's an adventure flick. In the novel, for example, Hammond isn't a kindly little elf, but an arrogant huckster, who doesn't see the hubris in what he's done, and he gets his comeuppance in the end.

I came out of the movie theater thinking, "Boy, if you could take out the scenes with the humans, leaving just footage of the dinosaurs, that would be a great movie." ("Walking With Dinosaurs" was produced a couple years later.)

I can enjoy watching it, certainly more than the sequels, but more often, I pick up the book are read it again.

Prost!
Brad
 
Star Trek VS Star wars

Star Wars for me everytime - though I did like Star Trek: The Next Generation and the Trek movies were good fun too.

As for TV Sci-Fi i'm a huge Doctor Who fan - but in terms of storyline and quality Babylon 5 was the best closely followed by Buffy.

Currently though the new version of Battlestar Galactica is the best show on TV. Awesome stuff.
 
Buffy,Next Generation,Voyager and DS9 for me.Could never get into Star Wars as i just couldn't take that Chewbacca and Robots seriously.Now 'Jaws' that was superb...can still remember the first bars of that music in the cinema before the curtains even parted.I thought it was the scariest music ever, until i heard 'Halloween':eek:

Rob
 
Buffy,Next Generation,Voyager and DS9 for me.Could never get into Star Wars as i just couldn't take that Chewbacca and Robots seriously.Now 'Jaws' that was superb...can still remember the first bars of that music in the cinema before the curtains even parted.I thought it was the scariest music ever, until i heard 'Halloween':eek:

Rob

John Williams is a brilliant conductor. I bought the soundtracks to "Star Wars", "The Empire Strikes Back" and "Superman" when they first came out. And I agree with you, his score for "Jaws" compliments the action and enhances the mood (except for the sprightly piece, when Quint first harpoons the shark, I always thought that was a little too light for the storyline).

Prost!
Brad
 
.....(except for the sprightly piece, when Quint first harpoons the shark, I always thought that was a little too light for the storyline).....

Oh, I don't know. Sprightly seemed appropriate to me, I mean, what was the worse that was going to happen to him.....:p
 
Here's a fitting item I first got back in 1997. From the home office, in Lee-banon, Pennsylvania, it's tonight's Top Ten list...

Top 10 Reasons "Star Wars" Characters Would Kick Butt in the "Star Trek" Universe:

10. In the "Star Wars" universe, weapons are rarely, if ever, set on stun.
9. The Enterprise needs a huge engine room with an anti-matter unit and a crew of 20, just to go into warp. The Millenium Falcon does the same thing with R2-D2 and a Wookie.
8. After resisting the Imperial torture droid and Darth Vader, Princess Leia still looked fresh and desirable--after pithy Cardassian starvation torture, Picard looked like hell.
7. One word: Lightsabers!
6. Darth Vader could choke the whole Borg empire with one glance
5. The Death Star doesn't care if a planet is Class M or not.
4. Luke Skywalker is not obsessed with sleeping with every alien he meets
3. Jabba the Hutt would eat Harry Mudd for trying to cut in on his action
2. The Federation would have to attempt to liberate any ship named Slave I

And the Number One reason "Star Wars" characters would kick butt in the "Star Trek" universe....

1. Picard pilots the Enterprise through an asteroid belt at one-quarter impulse power-Han Solo floors it.
 
Here's a fitting item I first got back in 1997. From the home office, in Lee-banon, Pennsylvania, it's tonight's Top Ten list...

Top 10 Reasons "Star Wars" Characters Would Kick Butt in the "Star Trek" Universe:

10. In the "Star Wars" universe, weapons are rarely, if ever, set on stun.
9. The Enterprise needs a huge engine room with an anti-matter unit and a crew of 20, just to go into warp. The Millenium Falcon does the same thing with R2-D2 and a Wookie.
8. After resisting the Imperial torture droid and Darth Vader, Princess Leia still looked fresh and desirable--after pithy Cardassian starvation torture, Picard looked like hell.
7. One word: Lightsabers!
6. Darth Vader could choke the whole Borg empire with one glance
5. The Death Star doesn't care if a planet is Class M or not.
4. Luke Skywalker is not obsessed with sleeping with every alien he meets
3. Jabba the Hutt would eat Harry Mudd for trying to cut in on his action
2. The Federation would have to attempt to liberate any ship named Slave I

And the Number One reason "Star Wars" characters would kick butt in the "Star Trek" universe....

1. Picard pilots the Enterprise through an asteroid belt at one-quarter impulse power-Han Solo floors it.
Good ones.:D:D I wouldn't try that in the Babylon 5 Universe however.:eek:
 
I am watching Doctor Who now. I say Doctor Who David Tennant is the best as the 10th doctor.

Well, I'd say he's as good as Tom Baker was as the Doctor. I think they're tied for the best, or maybe it's a three-way tie, including John Pertwee.

I think the quality of the writing helps, too. I think those three actors did an excellent turn, and each had a great interpretation of the character, but I also think that during each's tenure, he had good scripts, too.

Prost!
Brad
 
....but.....but.....Megan Fox.....how can that be ruining it?:confused:;)

Megan Fox has nothing to do with Transformers per se - the fact that she's the star attraction, and far more interesting than the giant transforming robots around her, speaks volumes about the rest of the quality of the movie. ;) Basically I just hate how they butchered the original transformers designs, now they all look like bugs, and the story is as horrible as any Michael Bay film.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top