1/32 vs. 1/35 ?? (1 Viewer)

[Aggie99]

So, I have a "scale" question.

Most of my soldiers are 1:32 Britains (or 54mm).

However, I saw some great stuff that was 1/35! I was concerned that there would be enough difference between 1/32 and 1/35, so I passed on the items.

My question is: Does anyone know how much of a difference there is between 1/32 and 1/35? Or are they pretty much the same, and can the figures go "together" relatively easy...!?

I am hoping this is a basic question and that someone can help me.

Thanks

 

[Martin Tabony]

In 1/32 6ft is 57mm in 1/35 6ft is 52mm so about 10% smaller I personaly think this is too much of a difference especialy if putting 1/32 figure with 1/35 vehicles. On the other hand if you intend to make dioramas then placing the smaller scales at the back can work.

Martin

 

[Phantom Warrior]

Keep in mind that the actual size of the figures can vary between manufacturers even when they are supposed to be the same scale. Generally, the size difference between 1/32 and 1/35 would be quite obvious.

Terry

 

[binder001]

The problem isn't just the 10% difference in size between "properly" scaled figures. The problem is that we are dealing in three dimensions, so the difference is cubed. That's why the 1/35th soldiers look like small Vietnamese or adolescents next to a 1/32nd scale figure. The problem is magnified by the fact that "54mm" is loosely interpereted. The current run of Conte/Britains/TSSD "54mm" figures tend to run much bulkier than a "true 1/32nd" scale figure.

It's your collection and you can do what you want, but personally I keep the 1/35th with the 1/35th and the 1/32 with the 1/32nd because I tend to see the differences.

Right now the 1/35th market is full of great kits and accessories. It is a shame that the scale differences add up.

Gary B.

 

[thebritfarmer]

I guess in the end it depends what you are buying and also what looks right to you.

A few buckets by a tent in the background probably would even be noticed. A figure say that stands head and shoulders above his horse would.

I have used 1:35 with Britains 1:32 and their new matte series and sizewise seems to work our great.

See for yourself, IMO it all works well and at the end of the day my friend is all that matters.

 

[katana]

Figures of different scales are only part of the problem. Weapons also vary with scale and can be a larger factor when mixing scales or even manufacturers within the same scale. Also manufacturers misidentify the scale their figures actually are and even if stated to be say 1/28 scale you need to compare side by side to be certain of compatability. Cando a subsidiary of Dragon has some very nice WWII plastic figures supposed to be 1/35 but when measured are actually 1/32. A 6 foot figure soles of feet to top of head in 1/35=52MM; 1/32= 57MM; 1/30= 61MM ; exclusive of helmets etc. Hope this helps; always remember Caviet Emptor

 

[Martin Tabony]

"This cow is small, that cow is far away" (Father Ted)

Martin

 

[trooper]

Figarti has the answer. When the size of their HMS Victory was queried with regard to scale their excuse was that it is "Toy" scale. The ultimate answer.

 

[Martin Tabony]

Figarti has the answer. When the size of their HMS Victory was queried with regard to scale their excuse was that it is "Toy" scale. The ultimate answer.

lol.

Martin

 

[jazzeum]

Isn't that what these are anyway? Toys for adults?

 

[trooper]

Isn't that what these are anyway? Toys for adults?

In that case why is there so much concern over scale? And why should the makers bother about accuracy? Considering the amount of research that goes into the manufacture of this product I find it rather insulting to have them dismissed as "toys" for adults.

 

[Mitch]

I think the realism, quality and expense of this hobby means quite simply, that if one states, as many do, that this is a true 1/30th scale miniature or 1/32nd or whatever then it should be. I don't go for this golden age malarcky but, what I do believe is that the collector base who spend lots of money are now more than ever accutely aware of detail, scale and the history behind the sets.

If you don't want the debates about scale then get it right or, say its as close as we are able to get to X or Y.

I agree about the ''toys'' bit they are for kids and cost an awful lot less the two words have nothing to do with each other in this hobby. I don't buy toys I buy collectable military miniatures.
Mitch

 

[gi546]

this depends on the maker.
Some manufactuers tend to a few liberties with their scale size, so every company is different.
here's a guide that the old nortwest trading company has:
http://www.oldnwtc.com/Old_NW_Site/cool_stuff_folder/sizes_folder/sizing_things_up.html

 

[katana]

I think the realism, quality and expense of this hobby means quite simply, that if one states, as many do, that this is a true 1/30th scale miniature or 1/32nd or whatever then it should be. I don't go for this golden age malarcky but, what I do believe is that the collector base who spend lots of money are now more than ever accutely aware of detail, scale and the history behind the sets.

If you don't want the debates about scale then get it right or, say its as close as we are able to get to X or Y.

I agree about the ''toys'' bit they are for kids and cost an awful lot less the two words have nothing to do with each other in this hobby. I don't buy toys I buy collectable military miniatures.
Mitch

Spot on target Mitch; at current price points stated scale should be adhered to. !/32 grew to 1/30 because of some manufacturers style choices! Unfortunatly it did not stop at 1/30 many figures are 65 MM which is 1/28 scale. Several recent vehicle releases also measure at 1/28 scale. All of this is fine if the customer is informed of what they are buying; 1/28 scale Military Miniatures Regards