Size Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers (1 Viewer)

[bradleyl30]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

Interesting, I was just thinking of my 10 year old nephew this morning. Remembering what it was like to be a child and how entertaining it was to reach over and poke your little sister to make her cry out and then act innocent.

Of course, I grew out of that long ago. I was remembering my sister's sage advice to my niece. "Jenna, if you ignore him he will eventually get bored and go annoy someone else."

Just food for thought and childish behavior.

 

[Hunter Rose]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

It clearly appears the WB 1/32 scale figures go along with the FL figures.........which look more like 1/32 scale versus 1/30 scale !

Wayne

So then based on that rational K&C must be producing 1/32 vehicles again and their Panzer IV is 1/32.

Why is K&C making 1/32 vehicles?

 

[braddinpa]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

Actually I thought Ken had said they moved from 1/32 to 1/30 a few years back? Britains stopped making 1/32 a few years ago. But maybe Ken can confirm. So I believe these measurements make sense. Oh, and thanks Julie for posting these. Very much appreciated.

 

[bradleyl30]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

Actually I thought Ken had said they moved from 1/32 to 1/30 a few years back? Britains stopped making 1/32 a few years ago. But maybe Ken can confirm. So I believe these measurements make sense. Oh, and thanks Julie for posting these. Very much appreciated.

Yes, this has been proven over, and over, and over, and over again.

 

[sammy719]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

Julie came up with a great thread in displaying various companies products next to one another for size comparison for our own eyes, it be a shame to turn a great idea and thread into another scale war, conspiracy gone wild thread, be nice to have one thread used for something positive for a change when it comes to comparing companies...Sammy

 

[maddadicus]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

Julie came up with a great thread in displaying various companies products next to one another for size comparison for our own eyes, it be a shame to turn a great idea and thread into another scale war, conspiracy gone wild thread, be nice to have one thread used for something positive for a change when it comes to comparing companies...Sammy

Maybe, if we cannot act like adults, this thread could continue without us being able to comment. It is a big deal for most of us to be able to see the differences and play matchy ,matchy with the sizes and styles of the different mfg.s that we choose to collect..Michael

 

[PanzerAce1944]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

Interesting, I was just thinking of my 10 year old nephew this morning. Remembering what it was like to be a child and how entertaining it was to reach over and poke your little sister to make her cry out and then act innocent.

Of course, I grew out of that long ago. I was remembering my sister's sage advice to my niece. "Jenna, if you ignore him he will eventually get bored and go annoy someone else."

Just food for thought and childish behavior.

Where is the....Childish Behavior ?
That being said, If I can not voice my opinion on how the Britains and FL WWII figures look the same size then Yes ....That is childish behavior !

Wayne

Wayne

 

[jazzeum]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

This thread was set up by Julie to show how figures compare one to another, not to engage in scale discussions.

Why don't we take it back there and if people want to discuss comparisons between FL and Britains figures, please create another thread.

 

[nysoldiers]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

How do K&C Greeks and Persians compare with First Legion's?

 

[PanzerAce1944]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

This thread was set up by Julie to show how figures compare one to another, not to engage in scale discussions.

Why don't we take it back there and if people want to discuss comparisons between FL and Britains figures, please create another thread.

What harm is it Comparing Scale of figures in a thread which is specifically comparing figures shown here side by side. People making snide comments should take a break and count to ten.
If one company says their figures are a given scale but blend well with other brands.....Great !

Wayne

 

[PanzerAce1944]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

How do K&C Greeks and Persians compare with First Legion's?

I would bet hands down that the First Legion Figures are much smaller than K&C.

Wayne

 

[wadepat]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

Gentle Friends,

Julie has gone above and beyond her usual duties to post comparison photos. These photos are amazingly helpful to folks who want to know how manufacturers' scales and styles compare. Discussion of differences in scale and style are certainly encouraged and, for many, they are highly useful. However, if strong opinions erupt into statements of which manufacturer's scale and style is best or whose opinion is the most valid, then you might discourage Julie from posting more useful photos and/or you run the risk of having this thread closed. By exercising civility, respect, and good judgement, this thread could be one of the best ones we have seen in a long time. Enjoy the thread, but please do so peacefully and appropriately.

Warmest personal regards,

Pat

 

[maddadicus]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

Gentle Friends,

Julie has gone above and beyond her usual duties to post comparison photos. These photos are amazingly helpful to folks who want to know how manufacturers' scales and styles compare. Discussion of differences in scale and style are certainly encouraged and, for many, they are highly useful. However, if strong opinions erupt into statements of which manufacturer's scale and style is best or whose opinion is the most valid, then you might discourage Julie from posting more useful photos and/or you run the risk of having this thread closed. By exercising civility, respect, and good judgement, this thread could be one of the best ones we have seen in a long time. Enjoy the thread, but please do so peacefully and appropriately.

Warmest personal regards,

Pat

QUITE FRANKLY, Julie is part of the management team who owns and hosts this forum. They do us a favor by allowing us to share in this hobby. Stop taking advantage of any assumed privilages that you think gives you the right to break protocal. If you cannot zip it, then leave this thread alone. Go disrupt someplace else. This is not a MANUFACTURES thread, but a hobby helpful one...Michael

 

[maddadicus]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

QUITE FRANKLY, Julie is part of the management team who owns and hosts this forum. They do us a favor by allowing us to share in this hobby. Stop taking advantage of any assumed privilages that you think gives you the right to break protocal. If you cannot zip it, then leave this thread alone. Go disrupt someplace else. This is not a MANUFACTURES thread, but a hobby helpful one...Michael

Also, as an add on, it has become obvious to all collectors that all manufactures have been fudging on their scale claims. All seem false, so why would anyone try to make points concerning doctored scale claims and questionable measurements. Side by side comparative photos would show if the mixed figures fit togther or not. Size is the new norm, not stated scales..Michael

 

[bradleyl30]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

I apologize for my role in the spat.

This is a valuable thread.

 

[jazzeum]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

I apologize for my role in the spat.

This is a valuable thread.

You have nothing to apologize for Larry.

Brad

 

[Julie]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

More photos for informational black & white in color purposes! I am trying to select similar poses from each Manufacturer when possible. This takes more time than you realize
Once again individual images with a ruler have been added to each product page on the Treefrog Treasures website.


K&C AG012 - FL AG009 - K&C AG029 - FL AG038

K&C AG012 - FL AG009 - K&C AG029 - FL AG038

K&C AG024 - FL AG046 - K&C AG020 - FL AG053

K&C AG024 - FL AG046 - K&C AG020 - FL AG053

Don't worry - I have not forgotten about the other WWII request - hoping that hits my afternoon session but I am trying to finish up some other piles in my office today as well. Slowly but surely I will add as time permits and products are in stock!

Julie

 

[braddinpa]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

Thanks for Posting all the comparisons Julie. It is greatly appreciated

 

[7th OVI]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

I agree, this is great for us to see the comparisons, appreciate the work that this takes. Chris

 

[farmertony]

Re: Scale Comparison Photos - Various Manufacturers

Well done Julie;Keep up the good work.This thread is both interesting and useful,especially for someone like me who lives in a relatively remote location and does not often get to see figures "in the flesh".If it is at all possible,I would like to see some Napoleonic comparisons-JJD,FL and K&C please.