Honour Bound Unweathered? (1 Viewer)

Yes thankyou for the voice of reason Eddy, I was going to say something along those lines myself, but you said it better than me. As for those unreal guys - bloody splitters (not another Monty Python joke :) )
 
This is a great discussion, German Armour colors are wildly varied, although I don't know if I have ever seen Aqua. But the great part of all of those participating in this discussion is what?........... We are all learning to "Get Real" and that is a good thing. The Manufacturers will read this also, and our hobby will be better for it. Thanks to all.........Alex
 
bricoleur said:
Dear Collectors;
I believe we can not discuss about the "real" colours of German armour. I went several times to Bovington and you see there a lot of private owned stuff. Every owner will paint his private piece in the colours he loves the most.
I have seen there the same splinter camo in at least four different yellow basetones, going from desert yellow to the greenish K&C yellow. Same for the brown colour: deep red brown, brick red and almost brownish black...
Ask the collectors in Bovington about the "real" colours... you get five different answers ans nobody has seen the "real" colours... (except the few colour propaganda films, made by the Germans in "no real" situations, nothing is left) The German army has received paint from at least ten different factories. The Tiger yellow was in most of the cases not the same as the Panther yellow as another company was delivering the paint for the panther production. In the field, tank commanders made there own "paintings", depending from what they could get and how nature was developing in the time of the year. My father has seen a lot of German armour in Belgium and France in that days and he always told me that from 1943 on, all the German halftracks and armour were almost completely covered by camo nets, bushes, leaves, mud and all kind of materials. He believes the colour scheme was no longer relevant. IMO the only "real" armour is the weathered edition, no matter what colours were used and mixed. Do not rely to much on the books and colour plates, made AFTER the war. The artist is giving you his colourset or he is refering to other artwork. My dad has seen several original panthers, just after the battle of the bulge before those pieces were dismantled. On all the panthers, almost 50% of the original paint was burned away (shell impact)
or simply rusted. That's why I love the heavy weathered models, no matter what colour is used.
Eddy:)

I am friends with Wild Bill Guarnere from Band of Brothers and we have talked about colors on a few occasions. The Airborne Normandy uniforms are weird, sometimes they look tan, and sometimes they look green, he said it was possibly the reaction of the chemical treatment for gas etc...etc. He was "Too busy eliminating Germans" to notice. We talked about German tanks a few times. They got his attention, and what you wrote is basically true. But I don't believe he ever mentioned seeing an Aqua one. I do have to admit ..... the Jagdpanther is a tempting piece, it is very striking:D ...Alex
 
Last edited:
Firebat said:
I am friends with Wild Bill Guarnere from Band of Brothers and we have talked about colors on a few occasions. The Airborne Normandy uniforms are weird, sometimes they look tan, and sometimes they look green, he said it was possibly the reaction of the chemical treatment for gas etc...etc. He was "Too busy eliminating Germans" to notice. We talked about German tanks a few times. They got his attention, and what you wrote is basically true. But I don't believe he ever mentioned seeing an Aqua one. I do have to admit ..... the Jagdpanther is a tempting piece, it is very striking:D ...Alex

Go for it Alex, it's a good one. Looks great with the tank riders (WS62). Let's pretend that the commander had inhaled some toxic gas just before repainting his tank:) .

Pierre.
 
That Jagdpanther is bending me a little. I have an idea to weather it with Pastel Chalks that can be washed off. I think there is a lot of leeway with the German Tanks. (This is philosophical, but there is a lot of that going around) As far as "Get Real", you didn't like it when I brought this up before, but The Job I have as a Battalion Fire Chief is very detail oriented and sometimes you don't know when to let go. So you carry that detail into everything you do. The lives of my Men and the citizens of the City I work in depend on it, so it becomes who you are. I am in a very tough City, so I carry this attitude to the max, and I guess even into my hobbies. Working at Ground Zero really blew me over the edge. Retirement will be in 18 months so maybe it is time to start easing down. So I will buy the Jagdpanther and pretend the crew was on Crack:D. Our discussions have remained civil, and maybe this explanation will further give you insight as to where I am coming from, so we can all work together to make it as real as possible...Firebat

You have got to admit.........I get some good fired up discussions going.........
 
Last edited:
I think we have a lot of good discussions going and that's a good thing. You'ved added new blood and that's also a good thing. I'm just a collector (and not that long either), not a dioramaist like you, so the more different points of view, the better.

Wait till you hold that Jag. It is heavy, almost as heavy as the HBs.
 
I think the Jagdpanther at the museum was repainted so its not the original colors.
 
jazzeum said:
I think we have a lot of good discussions going and that's a good thing. You'ved added new blood and that's also a good thing. I'm just a collector (and not that long either), not a dioramaist like you, so the more different points of view, the better.

Wait till you hold that Jag. It is heavy, almost as heavy as the HBs.

You are a Lawyer so you must be a good reader. Reading puts me to sleep, but I have about 200 reference books. When you learn about the pieces that are being replicated, where and how they were used, yes the coloring and weathering too, it adds a new dimension, and deepens your interst in the hobby. I believe you said you only do WWII, so do I. I have made it an all encompassing experience. I have made friends with Vets, researched events and vehicles, enjoy war movies, collect and make dioramas. I could teach you to do dioramas that would take you an hour to build, and they would look great. It makes such a powerful impact when your collection is displayed in such a way. I am in the process of creating my museum now, with the major focus on honoring those that served both in the Military and Firefighters. It is only one third done, but when people see it, they already get blown away, and they come away with a total experience. It is not just quantity but it also is quality, and how it is presented....Alex
 
bricoleur said:
Dear Collectors;
I believe we can not discuss about the "real" colours of German armour. I went several times to Bovington and you see there a lot of private owned stuff. Every owner will paint his private piece in the colours he loves the most.
I have seen there the same splinter camo in at least four different yellow basetones, going from desert yellow to the greenish K&C yellow. Same for the brown colour: deep red brown, brick red and almost brownish black...
Ask the collectors in Bovington about the "real" colours... you get five different answers ans nobody has seen the "real" colours... (except the few colour propaganda films, made by the Germans in "no real" situations, nothing is left) The German army has received paint from at least ten different factories. The Tiger yellow was in most of the cases not the same as the Panther yellow as another company was delivering the paint for the panther production. In the field, tank commanders made there own "paintings", depending from what they could get and how nature was developing in the time of the year. My father has seen a lot of German armour in Belgium and France in that days and he always told me that from 1943 on, all the German halftracks and armour were almost completely covered by camo nets, bushes, leaves, mud and all kind of materials. He believes the colour scheme was no longer relevant. IMO the only "real" armour is the weathered edition, no matter what colours were used and mixed. Do not rely to much on the books and colour plates, made AFTER the war. The artist is giving you his colourset or he is refering to other artwork. My dad has seen several original panthers, just after the battle of the bulge before those pieces were dismantled. On all the panthers, almost 50% of the original paint was burned away (shell impact)
or simply rusted. That's why I love the heavy weathered models, no matter what colour is used.
Eddy:)


Hi guys, I think we've been here before - at the sharp end there was considerable variation, nuff said?

Andy's stuff is on the mark almost all of the time. The Jag is a little off the main though I would agree and I wonder what source Andy used to paint it that way?
 
Pierre said:
A real "circus" Jagdpanther at the Bovington Tank Museum.

Pierre.

Have they got the Tiger going Yet? I a promised to take my son again this summer.
 
Hey Panda,

Where is this museum? If I come to London for the Toy Soldier show in December, could I get there? I'm trying to talk Hans and his wife into doing the trip with my wife and I. I would love to see you.

Regards,

Louis
 
Hi Louis

I would love to see you all, although slight note of caution though I might be away that week. (Not becauise you might be coming:eek: )

BTW we have a cook book for Hans' wife that our wives discussed last year.

Bovingdon is in Dorset, about 2 - 3 hours out of London depending upon the traffic. It is the Tank Museum (in the middle of the army tank firing ranges so you might have to dodge the odd Challenger on the way in) and has examples from the full history of the genre including WW1, inter war , WW2 and post WW2 specimens. It is excellent. :cool: The last time we went they had almost finished fully restoring a Tiger 1.

They have on display AFVs including german heavy armour and many Commonwealth and US examples.

I don't know if you saw my note about Beltring next week but that is even more impressive!!!!!! :eek: But temporary.:)

Kevin
 
Louis Badolato said:
Hey Panda,

Where is this museum? If I come to London for the Toy Soldier show in December, could I get there? I'm trying to talk Hans and his wife into doing the trip with my wife and I. I would love to see you.

Regards,

Louis

Hi Louis,

Have a look at www.tankmuseum.org

Pierre.
 
Pierre,

Thanks for the hyperlink. Cool website. I hope if I get to London that I can make a sidetrip and see the tank museum. If not, there's always the Imperial War Museum, where I can see a Jagpanther, a Cromwell, Monty's M3, and a Long Range Desert Group Chevy 30 CWT Truck recovered from the desert in Libya.

Regards,

Louis
 
panda1gen said:
Many thanks Pierre - do you come over to Beltring?

Never went to Beltring (nor Bovington) and not this year again.

When we went to London, we moved by taxis or metro. I just can't see me driving a car (to Kent or Dorset) the wrong side of the road;) . Even after a week, it was a complete adventure just to cross the street:D . But what a great city. And to everybody who are planning to go, don't miss the National Portrait Gallery, a must.

Pierre.
 
jazzeum said:
Well, I'm going to have to disagree with you there. It was one of the first K & C tanks and remains a favorite. These are models, not the real thing -- I'm not of the "get real" school -- and these are toy soldiers. Realism is important but it's not the end all and be all of military miniatures or toy soldiers. Should we discard everything because it is not exactly the way it was in real life. We made a big deal about the 101st. I knew it's important to you but not everybody feels that way.

yes yes ........ the price of this line (hb) is too high....... sory for this interference i dont want change the way of this thread



zup
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top