Mahdist Spears... (1 Viewer)

mikemiller1955

Lieutenant General
Joined
Aug 3, 2008
Messages
17,492
I noticed what seems to be a difference in the size of the spear heads and the length of the spears in the Wm. Brit Mahdist and the JJD's Mahdist...

the JJD's seem bigger...much bigger to me...but I only have pictures to look at...and I don't own any Wm. Brits...

can someone who owns both JJD's and Brit's comment on this...it's hard to tell in the Wm. Brit pictures because of the glare and the angle...

if you will look at the black and white photo...the spears on the wall look HUGE!!!

at least 9 feet with a monstrous head on them...

this article says the heads are almost 2 feet long...

The Mad Mahdi and the Sudanese War of 1885-98

In 1881 Islamic fundamentalist and religious scholar Mohammed Ahmed declared himself Mahdi, redeemer of Islam and raised an army to purify the Sudan of infidels. The Mahdi’s followers were largely equipped with their respective indigenous weapons and costume.

His elite troops were the Bagharras, mounted lancers who wore the patchwork jibba and carried huge spears know as shalaziehs.

***Based in form on traditional Sudanese spears, they were nearly twice as large and relate specifically to the Sudan campaign of 1885-98.***

They were considered to be talismanic, possessing magical protective powers. Items #733-737 are original Mahdist shalaziehs from the collection of the Haggerty Museum of Art, Milwaukee. These were undoubtedly captured at the Battle of Omdurman where 52,000 Sudanese troops suffered losses of 9700 killed, 13,000 wounded and 5000 captured. The heads are preserved in heavy varnish, probably applied in the Sudan by British troops.

***114 1/4” length with huge 23 1/2” head in heavy varnish showing some superficial darkening beneath, but crisp original finish. Short edge crack as made.***

if this is right...they were 9 1/2 feet long and the head was 2 feet long...

that's one GIANT SPEAR HEAD!!!

http://***anarms.com/extraordinarymahdistlancersspear-3.aspx

Mahdists.jpg


SUD01.jpg


SUD02.jpg



27015LR.jpg


27016LR.jpg


mahdi_2.jpg


09735b.jpg


09735c.jpg
 
It is my understanding that there was a great variation in spear types, especialy in the early years. Most of the Mahdi's followers would have had hunting tools rather than war weapons. By the time of Omdurman the Mahdist army was much more uniformed in clothing and equipment. As far as I am aware the Britains, Jenkins and Heritage ranges are all based in the early period. As to the model spearheads I think that is down to different manufacturing techniques, the Britains cast in one the Jenkins cast seperatly and assembled.

Martin
 
Here is a 19th C photo of a Fuzzy-Wuzzy with Spear
 

Attachments

  • egyptwarrior1.jpg
    egyptwarrior1.jpg
    28.5 KB · Views: 2,051
Here is a 19th C photo of a Fuzzy-Wuzzy with Spear

That spear hardly matches the size of the longer Mahdist's ones in the black and white photo and doesn't seem to follow the description of 9 1/2 foot long ones from the thread I posted...but there are also shorter ones in the photo...I'm really more curious about the head of the spear...I cannot see a close-up of the Wm. Brits...

I'm asking about the Mahdist's spears...not the Fuzzy Wuzzy's...

I know these spear heads are extremely broad and 2 feet long...

Randy...that article is about the Mahdist's spears...

I guessing the FW's had a much shorter different spear than the 9 footers of the Mahdist...

also look how wide the head of the spear is in the black and whites...it's wider than a man's face...
 
Last edited:
As far as I know...

JJD is not making any Fuzzy Wuzzy's...

not that he won't...just as far as I know...

I think he said he was introducing 16 Gordons...followed by an equal number of Mahdist...

the only Mahdist he has made so far are the ones for the Gordon's Khartoum diorama...

I'm sure everyone knows that the Fuzzy Wuzzy's were not Mahdist...

they were a Nomadic tribe from Egypt, Sudan and Africa that supported the Mahdists...

if anyone owns a Jenkins Mahdist and a Wm. Brit Mahdist...I would love to see a picture of them together...especially the size of their spear heads...

the original article I posted discussing the huge size of the spears and spear heads was specifically concerning Mahdist spears...
 
These are Mahdist spears...

not Fuzzy Wuzzy spears...

the spear head is enormous...not the usual narrow thin head...

mahdi_2-1.jpg
 
I don't have a photo, but the WB Mahdist spear heads are about half the width of JJ spear heads. WB ones look like the head in you photo, one in middle on shortest pole.

Donnie
 
Mike

The Fuzzy Wuzzies were an important part of the Mahdist movement. It is named for their leader the Mahdi or the anointed one. As a group they are also called Jihadists. Many different groups fought as Mahdists: Beja, Hadendoa, Baggara, Dervishes, Ansar, Riverine arabs, etc. You will see this if you look at the Perry's list of Mahdists. All these groups are considered Mahdist Warriors. See The Osprey book by Ian Knight: Queen Victoria's Enemies (2) Northern Africa In discussing the Sudan Mahdists it says that "The spearmen carried a large broad-bladed spear for thrusting, and a number of lighter weapons for throwing."

http://www.perry-miniatures.com/

Re John: John is doing the Battle of Tamai where both the Black Watch & Gordons fought against Mahdists that included the Fuzzy-Wuzzies as shown in the WB 2010 catalog

You will surely want to pick up Mike Snook's book the 1st of 2 definitive volumes he is doing on the Anglo-Sudan War
 

Attachments

  • go-strong-cover.jpg
    go-strong-cover.jpg
    79.1 KB · Views: 1,191
19th C Images of Mahdists with Spears

Sketch of the Mahdi's attack on the British army sent to try to rescue General Gordon in Khartoum, January, 1885. The battle took place at the Abu Klea wells in the Bayuda Desert.
Drawing by Captain Willoughby Verner, in Sketches in the Soudan. London: 1886.

Photograph of an officer in the Mahdist army of the Khalifa Abdullahi, captured by the British at the Battle of Toshka in Lower Nubia, 1889. He wears the unique patched costume of the Mahdi's followers. Known as the jibba, it was meant to symbolize one's devotion to God and the Mahdi as the Messiah of God.
Photo: Major F. R. Wingate.
 

Attachments

  • c1883-battle-abu-klea.jpg
    c1883-battle-abu-klea.jpg
    27.5 KB · Views: 1,266
  • c1883-mahdi-man.jpg
    c1883-mahdi-man.jpg
    15.5 KB · Views: 3,001
The Fuzzy Wuzzys fought "with" the Mahdist...

they were an entirely seperate group of warriors...

yes...they were part of the Mahdist forces...but they were actually a Nomadic tribe from along the Sudan's Red Sea Coast...

--------------------------------------------------------------------------
"The term fuzzy-wuzzy or fuzzy-wuzzies was first used by British soldiers in the Sudan to refer to a "specific tribe" of Sudanese who were fighting "under" the Mahdi in the two Sudan wars. The name is a reference to the tribe’s distinctive hairstyle. The Beja did not believe in cutting their hair and let it grow into long rat tails and large afros and greased it all with mutton fat".

http://www.suite101.com/content/fuzzywuzzy-a38195

--------------------------------------------------------------------------
"Fuzzy-Wuzzy" was the term used by British colonial soldiers for the nineteenth century Hadendoa warriors "supporting" the Sudanese Mahdi in the Mahdist War. The Beja people were one of two broad multi-tribal groupings supporting the Mahdi, and were divided into three tribes".

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuzzy-Wuzzy

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

they fought with a much smaller spear and a "crusader like" sword...

not the traditional spear...the shalaziehs"...of the Madhist themselves...

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

"In 1881 Islamic fundamentalist and religious scholar Mohammed Ahmed declared himself Mahdi, redeemer of Islam and raised an army to purify the Sudan of infidels. The Mahdi’s followers were largely equipped with their respective indigenous weapons and costume. His elite troops were the Bagharras, mounted lancers who wore the patchwork jibba and carried huge spears know as shalaziehs. Based in form on traditional Sudanese spears, they were nearly twice as large and relate specifically to the Sudan campaign of 1885-98. They were considered to be talismanic, possessing magical protective powers".

http://***anarms.com/extraordinarymahdistlancersspear-5.aspx

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

I think people are confusing the Fuzzy Wuzzys and Mahdists as the same people...they were not...they each had distinctive clothing, weapons and hairstyles...

but...this is getting away from my original question about the size of the spears...I'm hoping somebody can post a photos of only the JJD's Mahdist and Wm. Brits Mahdist...not the Wm. Brit Fuzzy Wuzzys...

I would like to see them together...
 
Randy...

this is a great picture you found of a "real life" Mahdist's spear...

not an artist rendering...

look at the size of the spear head...

the spear itself was 9 1/2 feet long with a 2 foot head...
 

Attachments

  • c1883-mahdi-man.jpg
    c1883-mahdi-man.jpg
    15.5 KB · Views: 231
Michael, I think the only true Sudanese Mahdists currently in the Britains catalog are the camal rider and the flag bearer, and neither have spears. All the other figures are sporting the long hair of the Beja tribe.
 
Michael, I think the only true Sudanese Mahdists currently in the Britains catalog are the camal rider and the flag bearer, and neither have spears. All the other figures are sporting the long hair of the Beja tribe.

I have not looked at them that close...but I think some certain liberties can be taken...especially with their hair...they all seem like lovely figures and I plan on ordering them regardless of spear or hair...I was just hoping somebody that owned the JJD's SUD01-02 or 03 Mahdists might also own some of the Wm. Brit Mahdist and I could get a photo of their spears...

living in Galveston...I have no opportunity to go to a retailer and look at them before I decide to purchase them...I think the closest retailer to me is Reno, Nevada...


even the JJD's Mahdist's spears are different...so...I wouldn't mind if the Wm. Brits are smaller or larger...I will still buy them I'm pretty sure...

SUD01.jpg
 
The Mahdist Army:

The best way to describe the Mahdi's army is as a motley crew whose dress and appearance evolved over time. Here is the section on the early Mahdist army from Ian Knight's Osprey volume on Victoria's enemies in North Africa which shows the Beja (Hadendoa) or Fuzzy-Wuzzies as part of the Mahdist forces. If you compare #2 and #4 you will see how the Fuzzy-Wuzzies appearance changed from their original tribal dress and long hair to the Mahdist style uniform and shaved heads.
 

Attachments

  • Mahdist1.jpg
    Mahdist1.jpg
    92.1 KB · Views: 3,608
  • MahdistTxt2.jpg
    MahdistTxt2.jpg
    76.6 KB · Views: 234
  • MahdistTxt.jpg
    MahdistTxt.jpg
    82.1 KB · Views: 237
Here are Knight's other two illustrations of the Mahdist army showing further evolution & variety--i.e. a "motley crue"
 

Attachments

  • Mahdist2.jpg
    Mahdist2.jpg
    94 KB · Views: 1,138
  • Mahdist3.jpg
    Mahdist3.jpg
    94.3 KB · Views: 1,941

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top