I'm sure not a Yankees fan by no means, but it seems in past playoffs, Johnny Damon, hediki matsui(spelling) were always around during crunch time, both are gone, those two had alot to do with last years world series run, so I'm thinking the Yanks are not as strong as last year, I.M.H.O. of course..Sammy
Damon and Matsui are both big losses from the lineup, there is njo question. However, because of Posada's age, he is not going to be able to catch more than 120 games this year, so we couldn't have a player useful only as a DH like Matsui, whose knees prevent him from playing the field. We replaced Matsui's .285 career average and 20-28 HR per year with Granderson's .270 career average and 25-35 HR per year, plus Granderson, who is a center fielder, will be a huge upgrade on Damon playing left field.
Damon as a number 2 hitter, batted around .290 with 18-25 HR per year, and around a .370 OBP. We replaced his bat with Nick Johnson, who was second in the league last year with a .425 on base percentage, so he will put men on base in front of the Yankee's big bats, Teixiera, A-Rod and Posada. With the short porch at Yankee Stadium, I expect Nick can hit about 15-20 HR. Obviously, he will not be a threat to steal bases, but with Melky gone and Gardner playing full time in Center, he should pick up a bunch of stolen bases.
The way I see it, the lineup should be 1. Jeter (.320+, 15-18 HR, .395 OBP), 2. N. Johnson (.290, 15-20 HR, .415+ OBP), 3. Teixiera (.290, 35-40 HR, 125+ RBI), 4. A-Rod (.290, 35-40 HR, 120+ RBI), 5. Posada (.275, 25-30 HR, 90+ RBI), 6. R. Cano (.320+, 20-28 HR, 75+ RBI), 7. Granderson (.260, 25-35 HR, 80+ RBI), 8. Swisher (.250, 25-30 HR, 75+ RBI), 9. Gardner (.260, 5 HR, 25-35 stolen bases). I think the Yankees offense will be just fine.