If my team catches the Tigers, I would pitch Burnett against him in game 1 (pretty much a sure loss, but who knows, he might pull one of those once in a season unhittable jems out of his butt), then pitch CC in game 2 (the Yankees should win, series tied 1-1), then the hottest of the two youngsters (probably Nova, possibly Hughes) in game 3 (the Yankees should win, Yankees up 2-1), forcing them to pitch Verlander vs. the other youngster in game 4 (Tigers win easily, series tied 2-2) and take my chances with CC on full rest against their second best starter in the deciding game 5.
If Boston catches the Tigers, do the same thing, thow Lackey out against Verlander in Game 1, then Beckett in game 2, Lester in game 3 (you should be up 2-1), forcing them to throw Verlander in game 4 against whoever, then pitch Beckett against their #2 in game 5. The key is don't waste your best starter against Verlander, assume he will win twice, and use your best starter twice against their #2 and your #2 against their #3, to win the series 3-2.