Everyones Top 5 War Movies (1 Viewer)

Interestingly, upon reviewing this thread, and after 5 years, I wouldn't change my list at all. ^&grin -- Al

the more recent version of the thin red line is actually more faithful to the novel,,minus the scenes with the locals etc,,several viewing are required to grasp james jones meanings,,just as the dated 50s version of here to eternity gets raves while the far superior version 1979 series,,tells the very true version of the novel,,and is little seen
 
Some movies here I haven't seen but from those I have seen, I would choose (oh boy, here comes the hard part):

-Apocalypse Now (more about art than realism, but extraordinary at that);
-The Deer Hunter (storyline, music, imagery, you name it);
-Lawrence of Arabia (monumental classic but much much more than the academic classic);
-A Bridge Too Far (stiff upper lip becomes extreme valour under extreme fire);
-Saving Private Ryan (that opening scene is possibly the best combat scene ever, and the rest of the movie is so poignant and a real homage to those who fell).

Of course I have to mention others:
-Sands of Iwo Jima
-The Last of the Mohicans
-Schindler's List
-The Downfall (tremendous performance by Bruno Ganz as Hitler and you can feel the last days/siege/bunker atmosphere suffocating you...)
-Gallipoli (poignant, excellent)
-The Thin Red Line
-Gladiator to me is not exactly a war movie, but the opening battle scene is outstanding, would love to see a Roman Empire war movie made to that standard.
-Excalibur by John Boorman
-Dr. Jivago, not exactly a war movie, but certainly an extraordinary, memorable depiction of people swept away by the Russian Civil War, would be in my top 2 if it was a war movie.

Saw Glory many years ago, but can't remember it that well now. I still have to see All's Quiet on the Western Front, both versions.
I also have to mention Band of Brothers surely the best war TV series ever (and one of the best TV series, war theme or not).
This is what I remember right now and I already have had to change my list twice:rolleyes2:.

Paulo

unfortunately as in many war movies,,most all the actors in the deer hunter were at least ten years too old for the parts they played,,example,,Sinatra in here to eternity at 40 playing the part of a 20 year old in the novel
 
the more recent version of the thin red line is actually more faithful to the novel,,minus the scenes with the locals etc,,several viewing are required to grasp james jones meanings,,just as the dated 50s version of here to eternity gets raves while the far superior version 1979 series,,tells the very true version of the novel,,and is little seen
it is the more recent version of TRL that I like. It, like The Searchers western of another thread, repays multiple viewings. There is much to see and understand. -- Al
 
were in you RVN? just wondering old boy,,,1st inf div 1966-67,,give a silent moment for those lost in the battle of sok trang,,1 july -4th 1966,,little known or remembered outside of 1st div history,,my rgt..2nd bn 18 inf
No mate, RVN? no idea what that is. I was too young to go to Vietnam luckily for me. I know about Aussie military history but know zip about U.S, BUT SALUTE ALL WHO SERVED.
Wayne.
 
No mate, RVN? no idea what that is. I was too young to go to Vietnam luckily for me. I know about Aussie military history but know zip about U.S, BUT SALUTE ALL WHO SERVED.
Wayne.
Wayne, RVN stands for Republic of Viet Nam. You answered Bromhead's question anyhow. -- Al
 
We have been going back and forth on favorite war movies. How about this. Eveyone list their top 5 war movies, #1 thru #5.
No comments on the movies, no more than their top 5.
And we will see what we come up with.
Again only 5, and no comments.
#1 SPR
#2 Paths of Glory
#3 Platoon
#4 Full Metal Jacket
#5 Das Boot
Gary
1 A Bridge Too Far
2 Platoon
3 Odd Angry Shot
4 They Died with Their Boots On (Errol Flynn)
5 A Walk in the Sun

One Aussie movie and a Errol Flynn ACW movie.....cheers TomB
 
Hard to pick 5, but ...
Saving Private Ryan - The realism of this movie is breathtaking.

Gettysburg - good portrayal of segments of the battle; my favorite moments - Chamberlain shouting "Bayonet!," Pickett shouting "Up men and to your posts," and the 69th PA rising to deliver its first volley.

Glory- not completely accurate to 54th MA, but good portrayal of overall experience of black soldiers; excellent, gritty battle scenes

Full Metal Jacket - the basic training half is unsurpassed.

Shenandoah - I had a hard time choosing, so I picked this classic Civil War movie from my childhood.
 
Very good selections all. I have to go with:

1. Gettysburg.
2. Alamo (1960 version).
3. Zulu.
4. Glory.
5. Last of Mohicans (1990 version)

Walt
 
I've just had a look thorough my war dvd collection (124 so far), and my top five atm are:

1. SPR
2. Cross of Iron
3. A Bridge to Far
4. The Eagle has Landed
5. Battle of Britain

It's Five years since my above post and I still watch 3. and 4. on a regular basis, and good old Michael Caine appears in both. He plays a convincing young Lt-Col J.O.E. Vandeleur in "A Bridge To Far", and is even better (IMO) as Oberst Kurt Steiner in "The Eagle has Landed" which also starred Donald Sutherland, Jenny Agutter and Robert Duvall in very believable roles.
 
This is a tough one! I would select the following:

1. Gettysburg
2. Battle of the Bulge
3. A Bridge to Far
4. Saving Private Ryan
5. Glory

If you expand the list, I would include "Gods and Generals" which covered the Battles of Fredericksburg and Chancellorvile; Zulu; Zulu Dawn, the series Band of Brothers, and Pacific, and finally "300" for the Greek / Persian war.
 
Last edited:
1. Saving Private Ryan
2. Black Hawk Down
3. A bridge too far
4. Platoon
5. Von Ryan's Express

Tom
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top