The Giants again played down to their competition, but, thanks to a great performance from Eli (349 yards, 2 touchdowns, no interceptions) they pulled it out 20-17. Its strange watching this team. They cannot run the ball (particularly Brandon Jacobs, who is a 260 lb running back who looks like a ballerina out there), yet Gilbride insists on trying to run on almost every first down, and if they pass on first down, they inevitably run on second down. Eli Manning has backed up his rather uncharacteristic (the guy is so vanilla I never expected a comment like that) boast that he is an elite quarterback with a 13 touchdown, 5 interception start to the season wherein he has thrown for more than 300 yards in all but the first game of the season, despite receivers who dropped no less than 8 balls in today's game alone. The defense looks fantastic against the pass, but allows second rate quarterbacks to run the ball like the second incarnation of Barry Sanders, plus they struggle when they have to stop the run, even in obvious running situations.
The Giants have a brutal schedule for the remainder of the year, starting with a good test game on the road against New England next week. New England, like the Giants, is an enigmatic team, blowing a 21 point lead to lose to the Bills, and looking like hell today against the Steelers, while looking like champs in other weeks. Frankly, I would not be shocked if the Giants went into Foxboro and won, and I would not be shocked if the Giants lost by 3 touchdowns either. This team is impossible to read week to week.
By the way, what did you think of Tim Tebow today against a team not the Dolphins? The Tebow Era will end by the end of this season, due to a combination of ineffectiveness and injury (did you see the hit in the 4th quarter when he finally converted his first 3rd down of the game by running for 12 yards on a 3rd and 7, then getting rocked by a safety, flipped head over heels, and landing, looking dazed, flat on his butt?). You have to love the idiot commentators talking about how he can just will a team to win. Maybe against a winless team that hasn't played 60 minutes all season, not against a competitive NFL team.