Couple of interesting articles in today's Times:
Carroll's decision, analyzed by a Professor of Game Theory
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/03/u...ensible.html?ref=football&_r=0&abt=0002&abg=1
The Fumble. Another infamous poor decision. In 1978 Joe Pisarcik, the Giants QB, handed off the ball to Larry Csonka on the last play of a meaningless game. The ball was fumbled, Herman Edwards of the Eagles scooped it up and scored and the Giants lost. The focus of the article, Bob Gibson, the Offensive Coordinator, was fired and never worked in football again.
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/03/s...ts-call-ended-an-nfl-career.html?ref=football
The Fumble had beneficial results actually. Giant fans hired an airplane to fly a banner over Giants Stadium reading "20 Years of Lousy Football, We've had Enough." The Giants owners, the brothers Mara were feuding and as a result of the Fumble and the banner, Pete Rozelle decided it wasn't good for business to have a perennially losing Giants franchise and forced them to agree to hire George Young as GM. The rest is history as Young built the team that led to two SB titles, whose staff included Tom Coughlan.