My bi-monthly rant about the state of today's starting pitching vs 'the good ole' days' got me to thinking about the various pitchers I have seen since I became a fan. I went back and studied starters since 1960 to see how things stacked up, today vs yesterday. I picked 1960 because that's about when I became a fan so it seemed a good place to start. I decided to pick 3 criteria just to see how pitchers stacked up on a brief basis. I picked ERA, innings pitched average over a 162 game season, and wins averaged over a 162 game season. The caveat here is this is not a comprehensive list. I went off my memory of big name pitchers and pitchers with long careers. It is possible I missed someone but I think I got most of the big ones. Since 1960, ONE pitcher has averaged as many as 18 wins per 162 game season, Juan Marichal @ 18-10. Ten pitchers have averaged 17 wins: Ford and Martinez (Pedro) went 17-8; Johnson (Randy), Clemens, Halladay, and Guidry all averaged a 17-9 record; Mussina, Pettitte, and Palmer went 17-10, and Bob Gibson averaged a 17-12 record. Everyone else in that period fell below the 17 win mark. Some of the best ever, like Seaver, Maddux, and Koufax "only" reached 16 wins on average.
Since 1960, in terms of ERA, only 8 pitchers were under 3.00. They were Ford @ 2.75, Koufax @ 2.76, Palmer @ 2.86, Seaver @ 2.86, Marichal @ 2.89, Gibson @ 2.91, Martinez @ 2.93, and Drysdale @ 2.95. Once again, many big names you will remember, like Perry, Carlton, Ryan, Maddux, Glavine, Jenkins, Halladay, Lee, Oswalt, all had ERA's north of 3.00.
Finally I came to innings averaged per 162 game season, using 240 as the magic number. 8 pitchers reached this number of innings per season: Gibson @ 262, Marichal @ 257, Seaver @ 250, Palmer @ 249, Perry @ 248, Carlton @ 245, Jenkins @ 243, and Morris @ 242.
Make of it what you will. Only 3 pitchers scored in the top of all 3 categories, Marichal, Gibson, and Palmer. Other greats, like Seaver, Martinez, and Ford, all placed high in 2 of the 3 categories. Everyone else scored high in 1 category. I realize this is strictly a numbers game (and I may have missed someone) and doesn't take in the intangibles such as post-season but it does give a good idea of the top pitchers of the last 50+ seasons. And before the Koufax lovers all jump on me, his averages of a 16-8 won/loss record, and 222 innings pitched per average 162 game season, placed him out of the top numbers in 2 of the 3 categories. Remember, these were just my arbitrary criteria for ranking pitchers and it isn't scientific, official, or even correct. It's just numbers.
Anyone care to add anyone? I can check the numbers for arguments sake. -- Al