Very true Noah. If would almost be impossible to pick one image for a hypothetical catalog cover from all the photographers mentioned. I think the only solution then is to have a FL calendar, because then we wouldn't have to select only one pic. What image to put on the cover would still be in question I suppose, but this could easily be remedied by either A) putting FL's logo only on the cover, B) using a collage of pics from multiple artists & ranges, C) having a contest/vote for the cover image, or D) limiting the choices to Napoleonic pics only for the cover since that's FL's flagship line. (Of course there is no catalog or calendar in the works that I'm aware of....just having fun with the idea of getting some of these photographer's images published.)
But back to Joe's pic, it just really struck a chord with me......the story, the figures, the setting, the lighting, my interest in the subject matter.....the overall realism of it all. It looks very much like a painting to me.
Joe