I did. Results unequivocal. Russia and Europe very size aware, Anglo saxon environment depending on collecting preferences. I noticed the answer had a lot to do with which brands the dealer was representing, so I did not give much value to the results.
Then did a survey of manufacturers (KC, FL, Britains & JJD) and those results were different from your statement. Therefore, I ask you support your statement.
Andanna,
It is most impressive that you consulted Russian, European (France, Germany and Italy I am guessing) and "Anglo Saxon" dealers to support your view. Pity you did not give much value to the results. Pretty sure the 4 producers would have had quite varying views.
As an Anglo Saxon / Aussie dealer my experience is based on selling five current five brands (ie K&C, JJ, WB, CS and TG) and previously selling Conte and East of India. Have also read multiple such threads here over about 12 years.
Compatability of figures would be great but the reality is it never going to happen.
In my experience subject matter is the first choice a new buyer will consider. With many series there is no option (ie. current JJ Aztecs , WB Vikings, KC English Civil War, JJ WW1 aircraft, TG Pacific Aussies, CS Iraq to name a few). In some areas there are multiple choices such as ACW and Naps where most brands have done them. At this stage factors such as price and variety in the series come into it. Some collectors will stick to one brand but others are happy to mix. The reason people will be happy to mix is because one brand does not have all the poses they seek. Then they are prepared to go with others that may be slightly different in size, style and colour. I often use Zulu v 24th as an example. I have had Conte and WB series. Personally I would not mix Red 24th but no problem mixing Zulus who are not so uniform. However if you like the Conte's Michael Caine and Stanley Baker you might have been tempted to use them with Britains.
The "scale" issue is much more of a factor for those combining WW2 figures and armour and this is reflected in threads here. Such posters are concerned about figure size relative to tanks and combining them with other brands. Not only do the figures have to work together to their satisfaction but so do the vehicles. A look at the many scale threads reveals it is a very small band who make multiple posts about the subject. For example if you looked at Australian comments in these threads you would probably find well over 50% of them made by one person
salute:
. Katana's scale comments alone would outnumber the comments by European, Russian and Australian members.
However you dont see ACW or Nap collectors lamenting the fact brands might not mix together. IMHO it is the WW2 armour fans where scale is a particular issue and I am guessing many are former model kit makers where attention to detail is more of an issue. Good luck to them but in my world it does not rate as in issue in a shop environment.
For mail order the buyer might not be sure and it should be easy to ask any dealer to take quick pics comparing current different brands or figures with a vehicle etc.
Just my $2 worth but feel free to discount my thoughts as just my opinion. I did however consult 100 collectors before making this post so it is "unequivocal" although I did not give much value to some who did not agree with me.^&grin