Rob..
Thats my point. I see no reason why one should not be able, as you say, to ra ra on this thread and, I am not sure who has said that but, should not have as, clearly thats stupid. On the whole most threads are positive with some great sets and great pics but, as with anything there are faults issues etc that posters wich to get off their chest. Lets take prices as its the thread we are on this thread does not really derail any of the ra ra but, allows posters who may have no other outlet to vent their concerns and worries etc over their hobby.
The two can really co-exist and does not need anyone to come on and say either how boring it is or, this or that about what people are saying undermine their intelligence as they post what they believe just, as it would be wrong to deliberately do that on the ra ra.
I see far more posts either spoilt or closed in relation to price quality etc than I do being spoilt by the negative comments or restriction of the ra ra threads. I think we have discussed this before that one can immediately tell who wants to stir or be naughty on a thread and those who wish to post their concerns and ra ra's on a thread.
I remember a similar discussion when Vezzolf was berated for comments after I had just joined and, asked why he should not be allowed his opinion on an open forum. I was told that I would get bored of the comments after a while and the way these threads repeated themselves. Well, I am never bored about whats posted good or bad is interesting IMO.
Every opinion is important and whilst I may not agree its part of the rich tapestry that makes the forum so good and, people again, IMO should not be quietened, censored or haranged so they feel they should not post what they feel as it may bore members.
Mitch
But sometimes it works exactly the opposite way Mitch, sometimes some of us are told we shouldn't post ra ra posts here either, so it seems some want to only post negative posts and shout down those who want to enjoy the hobby and celebration of it. If it's good for the goose it's good for the gander so to speak.
Rob